McCormick & Schmick's Broiled Seafood Platter: A Guide to Recreating the Classic

Learn how to build a broiled seafood platter inspired by McCormick & Schmick's, covering seafood counter choices, flavors, textures, portions, pairings, and serving tips for a memorable meal.

4 min readBroiling Seafood11 viewsMcCormick & Schmick's Broiled Seafood Platter: A Guide to Recreating the Classic
— · 0 votes
Contents
  1. What Is McCormick & Schmick's Broiled Seafood Platter?
  2. Choosing Seafood at the Counter for Your Platter
  3. Best Seafood Options for Broiling
  4. Portions Per Person
  5. Flavor and Texture Comparisons
  6. How to Prepare and Broil a Seafood Platter
  7. Serving Ideas and Pairings
  8. Make-Ahead and Safe Handling Tips
  9. Building a Platter for Your Occasion

What Is McCormick & Schmick's Broiled Seafood Platter?

McCormick & Schmick's broiled seafood platter is a signature restaurant menu item that showcases a generous assortment of fresh seafood, simply broiled to highlight natural flavors. Typically, it includes a mix of fish fillets, shrimp, scallops, and sometimes lobster or crab, served with lemon, drawn butter, and complementary sides. The platter is designed for sharing or as a hearty entrée, emphasizing the quality of the seafood rather than heavy sauces.

When planning your own version, focus on variety and freshness. Choose at least three types of seafood with different textures and flavors—such as firm white fish, sweet shellfish, and rich salmon—to create a balanced, satisfying platter.

Choosing Seafood at the Counter for Your Platter

A great broiled seafood platter starts with smart selections at the seafood counter. Look for bright, clear eyes on whole fish, firm flesh that springs back when touched, and a clean, ocean-like smell. For shellfish, ensure shells are intact and closed (or close when tapped). If fresh isn't available, high-quality frozen seafood—especially shrimp and scallops—can be excellent.

Best Seafood Options for Broiling

  • Firm white fish: halibut, cod, sea bass, or mahi-mahi. They hold up well under the broiler and have a mild, slightly sweet flavor.
  • Rich, oily fish: salmon or arctic char. These add a buttery texture and deeper flavor.
  • Shrimp: large or jumbo shrimp, peeled and deveined, cook quickly and have a sweet, snappy bite.
  • Scallops: sea scallops, dry-packed if possible, caramelize beautifully under high heat.
  • Lobster tails or crab legs: for a luxurious touch, split lobster tails or pre-cooked crab legs can be broiled briefly.

Portions Per Person

For a main course platter, plan on 6–8 ounces of seafood per person. If serving as part of a larger meal or as an appetizer, 3–4 ounces per person is sufficient. A mixed platter might include one small fish fillet, three shrimp, two scallops, and half a lobster tail per guest.

Flavor and Texture Comparisons

Understanding the differences in flavor and texture helps you build a platter that excites the palate. The table below compares common broiling choices.

SeafoodFlavorTextureBroiling Notes
HalibutMild, sweetFirm, meaty, large flakesBroil 4–6 minutes per 1/2 inch thickness; avoid overcooking.
SalmonRich, butteryMedium-firm, moist flakesBroil skin-side down for 6–10 minutes; internal temp 125–130°F for medium.
ShrimpSweet, brinyFirm, snappyBroil 2–3 minutes per side until pink and opaque.
Sea scallopsSweet, delicateTender, succulentBroil 3–4 minutes per side; don't overcook or they become rubbery.
Lobster tailSweet, richFirm, slightly chewySplit and broil 5–8 minutes; internal temp 140°F.

How to Prepare and Broil a Seafood Platter

Broiling uses high, direct heat from above, quickly cooking seafood while creating a lightly browned, flavorful exterior. Follow these steps for a foolproof platter.

  1. Preheat the broiler: Set the oven rack 4–6 inches from the heat source. Preheat for at least 5 minutes.
  2. Prepare the seafood: Pat all seafood dry with paper towels. Season lightly with salt, pepper, and optional spices or herbs. Brush with olive oil or melted butter.
  3. Arrange on a sheet pan: Place seafood in a single layer, leaving space between pieces. Group items with similar cooking times together, or add quicker-cooking items later.
  4. Broil in stages: Start with the thickest, longest-cooking items (like fish fillets or lobster tails). After a few minutes, add shrimp and scallops to the pan. Broil until each piece is cooked through and lightly browned.
  5. Rest and serve: Remove from the oven and let rest for 2–3 minutes. Serve with lemon wedges and drawn butter.

Temperature guide: Fish is done at 145°F (or 125–130°F for medium salmon). Shrimp and scallops should reach 120–130°F, but visual cues—pink and opaque shrimp, opaque and firm scallops—are reliable.

Serving Ideas and Pairings

A broiled seafood platter is versatile and pairs well with simple, bright sides that complement without overpowering.

  • Classic sides: Steamed asparagus, roasted baby potatoes, rice pilaf, or a fresh green salad.
  • Sauces: Drawn butter, lemon butter, tartar sauce, cocktail sauce, or a light herb gremolata.
  • Wine pairings: Crisp white wines like Sauvignon Blanc, Pinot Grigio, or unoaked Chardonnay. For a richer platter with salmon, try a light Pinot Noir.
  • Bread: Warm crusty bread or garlic bread for soaking up juices.

Make-Ahead and Safe Handling Tips

You can prepare components ahead: season the seafood and make sauces up to a few hours in advance, storing them covered in the refrigerator. However, broil just before serving for best texture. Keep raw seafood refrigerated at 40°F or below until ready to cook, and avoid cross-contamination by using separate cutting boards and utensils. Leftovers should be refrigerated within 2 hours and consumed within 2 days.

Building a Platter for Your Occasion

Adapt the broiled seafood platter to your budget, time, and gathering size. For a casual weeknight meal, choose shrimp and a firm white fish with simple seasonings. For a special occasion, add lobster tails or diver scallops and serve with elegant sides. A platter is inherently communal—place it in the center of the table and let guests help themselves, creating a warm, shared dining experience reminiscent of a fine restaurant menu like McCormick & Schmick's.

By starting with quality seafood and respecting its natural flavors, you can recreate the essence of a broiled seafood platter at home, tailored to your taste and occasion.

Related articles