Cooking Whole Foods Crab Cakes

How to cook store-bought Whole Foods crab cakes in the oven or a pan, how to tell when they are done, and how to reheat leftovers without drying them out.

8 min read5 viewsCooking Whole Foods Crab Cakes
— · 0 votes
Contents
  1. Reading the package cooking instructions
  2. Oven baking crab cakes on a sheet pan
  3. Pan frying for a crisp crust
  4. Judging when a crab cake is done
  5. Cooking from frozen versus thawed
  6. Reheating leftover crab cakes
  7. Serving and pairing crab cakes
  8. Questions About Cooking Crab Cakes
  9. Do I need to cook Whole Foods crab cakes before eating them?
  10. What are the cooking instructions for Whole Foods crab cakes?
  11. Can I pan fry crab cakes instead of baking them?
  12. How do I reheat crab cakes without drying them out?
  13. How can I tell when a crab cake is fully heated?

Cooking Whole Foods crab cakes means following the package cooking instructions for the oven or stovetop and heating them until the center is hot and the outside is crisp. The crab is already cooked, so your job is to bring the cakes up to temperature without drying out the meat. Oven baking suits a batch, while pan frying gives a darker crust.

  • The crab in store-bought crab cakes is already cooked, so you are reheating rather than cooking raw seafood.
  • Read the package cooking instructions first, because oven temperature and time depend on the size and weight of the cakes.
  • An instant-read thermometer pushed into the center is the surest way to know a crab cake is hot through.
  • Pan frying gives a crisp crust but needs a hot pan and a little oil so the cakes do not stick.
  • Reheat leftover crab cakes gently in the oven or a skillet, since high heat toughens the crab.

Reading the package cooking instructions

Cooking Whole Foods crab cakes starts with the label on the package, which gives the oven temperature and the time for that specific size of cake. Crab cakes from the seafood counter and boxed frozen ones can differ in weight and thickness, so a single time does not fit all. Follow the instructions that came with your package rather than a recipe written for another product.

The package cooking instructions often list more than one method, and each one has its own temperature and timing. Pick the method that matches the equipment you have and the crust you want. If the label is missing or unreadable, ask the seafood counter staff for the cooking guidance for that product.

Check the label for whether the crab cakes are sold fresh or frozen, because frozen cakes need longer in the oven. Thaw frozen crab cakes in the refrigerator before cooking so the center and the crust finish at the same time. Do not thaw them on a warm counter, since that invites bacterial growth.

Oven baking crab cakes on a sheet pan

Oven baking is the easiest way to cook several Whole Foods crab cakes at once with even heat. Heat the oven to the temperature on the package and line a sheet pan with parchment or lightly oil it. Space the cakes apart so hot air reaches every side and the crust sets evenly.

Arrange the crab cakes on the pan in a single layer and slide them into the hot oven. Bake for the time the package gives, then check the center with an instant-read thermometer. The cakes are ready when the middle is hot and the surface is golden at the edges.

For a crisper top, brush the cakes with a little melted butter or oil before baking. A wire rack set in the sheet pan lifts the cakes off the surface and lets the bottom crisp. Let baked crab cakes rest for a couple of minutes before serving, so they hold together when lifted.

Pan frying for a crisp crust

Pan frying crab cakes gives a browned, crunchy crust that oven baking does not match. Set a skillet over medium heat and add enough oil to coat the bottom thinly. Wait until the oil shimmers before adding the cakes, or they will soak up fat and stick.

Lay the crab cakes in the pan with space between them and leave them alone for the first few minutes. A crust forms only when the cake sits still against the hot surface. Turn each cake once with a thin spatula when the underside is deeply golden.

Cook the second side until browned and check the center with a thermometer before serving. Pan frying on medium rather than high heat lets the middle heat through before the outside burns. Wipe the pan and add fresh oil between batches so the crust stays clean.

Judging when a crab cake is done

A crab cake is done when the center is hot and the outside is crisp and golden, not when a timer alone says so. The crab is already cooked, so the goal is even heat through the cake. Push an instant-read thermometer into the middle of the thickest cake to check.

The cakes should feel firm at the center and spring back when pressed lightly with a spatula. A cold middle shows as a soft, cool patch even when the crust looks finished. Return undercooked cakes to the oven or pan for a few more minutes and check again.

Overcooking dries the crab and makes the binder rubbery, so pull the cakes as soon as the center is hot. Holding them in a warm oven after cooking continues to firm them. Serve crab cakes soon after cooking for the best texture.

Cooking from frozen versus thawed

Frozen crab cakes take longer to heat through than thawed ones because the cold center resists the oven heat. Thawing in the refrigerator overnight gives the most even result and keeps the cakes intact. Cook thawed cakes by the package method for the shorter time it lists.

If you cook crab cakes straight from frozen, use the frozen instructions on the package and expect a longer bake. A lower oven temperature helps the center catch up with the crust. Check the middle with a thermometer rather than relying on the crust color alone.

Thawed crab cakes hold their shape better in a skillet, so pan frying suits them. Frozen cakes can release water into the pan and spatter, which makes browning harder. Oven baking handles frozen cakes with less mess.

Reheating leftover crab cakes

Reheating crab cakes calls for gentle heat, because a second blast of high heat toughens the crab and dries the binder. A moderate oven or a covered skillet warms the middle without recrisping the outside to a hard shell. Leftover cakes keep their shape better when handled with a spatula.

Place leftovers on a sheet pan in a moderate oven until the center is hot, turning once. A skillet over medium-low heat with a lid traps steam and warms the cake through. Avoid a microwave on high, which heats unevenly and makes the crust soggy.

Reheat only the cakes you plan to eat, since repeated warming dries the crab further. Serve reheated cakes with a fresh sauce or a squeeze of lemon to bring back moisture. Cool any uneaten cakes quickly and refrigerate them.

Serving and pairing crab cakes

Crab cakes belong on a plate with something bright and something soft to balance the rich, salty crab. A green salad, sliced tomatoes or coleslaw adds freshness against the browned crust. A squeeze of lemon or a spoon of tartar sauce lifts the flavor of the crab.

For a gathered table, serve crab cakes as a main with roasted potatoes or rice and a simple vegetable. Smaller cakes work as a starter or a sandwich filling on a soft bun. Keep sauces light so the crab remains the focus of the plate.

Plate crab cakes soon after cooking, while the crust is still crisp and the center is hot. A wedge of lemon and a scattering of herbs finish the plate without hiding the seafood. Offer the sauce on the side so each diner chooses how much to add.

Questions About Cooking Crab Cakes

Do I need to cook Whole Foods crab cakes before eating them?

Yes, Whole Foods crab cakes are sold to be cooked before eating, even though the crab inside is already cooked. Heating them brings the center to a safe temperature and crisps the crust. Follow the package cooking instructions for the oven or stovetop.

What are the cooking instructions for Whole Foods crab cakes?

The cooking instructions for Whole Foods crab cakes are printed on the package and give an oven temperature and time for that product. Many packages also list a pan-frying method with its own heat level and timing. Use the method that suits your equipment and check the center with a thermometer.

Can I pan fry crab cakes instead of baking them?

Yes, pan frying works well for crab cakes and gives a darker, crisper crust than oven baking. Use medium heat and a thin layer of oil, and turn the cakes once when the underside is golden. Check the middle with an instant-read thermometer before serving.

How do I reheat crab cakes without drying them out?

Reheat crab cakes gently in a moderate oven or a covered skillet over medium-low heat until the center is hot. High heat toughens the crab and dries the binder, so keep the temperature moderate. A microwave on high heats unevenly and softens the crust.

How can I tell when a crab cake is fully heated?

A crab cake is fully heated when an instant-read thermometer pushed into its center reads hot and the middle feels firm. The outside should be golden and crisp at the same time. If the center is still cool, return the cake to the oven or pan for a few more minutes.

Read next

Latest articles