What to Do with Leftover Fish Pie
Practical ways to reheat leftover fish pie safely and turn it into fish croquettes, a crispy hash or a second bake with a fresh topping.
Contents
Leftover fish pie is easy to reuse when you treat the filling and the topping as two separate ingredients. The filling reheats gently and can become croquettes or a hash, while the mashed potato topping crisps well under a hot grill. The main thing to watch is temperature, since a pie made with fish and a creamy sauce needs even heat all the way through. Below are the practical routes from a cold wedge of pie to a hot plate.
Reheating a slice of pie
Fish pie reheating works best when you loosen the filling and warm it before the topping dries out. Put the portion in an ovenproof dish and add a splash of milk to the sauce so it does not tighten. Cover the dish with foil and heat it in a moderate oven, then uncover it for the last few minutes so the potato topping turns golden. Check that the center is steaming hot before you serve it.
Getting the topping crisp again
A leftover fish pie topping turns soft in the refrigerator, and a dry heat source brings the crust back. Spoon the cold mash into a hot pan with a little butter and press it down to make a flat cake. Fry the cake until the underside is brown and crisp, then flip it carefully with a wide spatula. Alternatively, spread the mash on a tray and let it crisp under a hot grill while you watch it closely.
Turning pie into croquettes or hash
Fish croquettes and fish pie hash are the two ways to stretch a small leftover portion into a new dish. For croquettes, chill the filling until firm, roll it into short logs, coat them in flour, egg and breadcrumbs, then fry them until golden. For fish pie hash, break the potato topping into pieces and fry it with the flaked filling and a chopped onion until the edges catch. Both dishes taste best when the filling is cold and firm before you shape or fry it.
Questions About Leftover Fish Pie
Can you reheat leftover fish pie?
Yes, leftover fish pie can be reheated, provided it was chilled quickly and stored in the refrigerator. Heat it covered in a moderate oven so the filling warms through without the potato topping drying out. Reheat only the portion you plan to eat and let it steam hot before serving. Fish pie that has sat out at room temperature should be discarded rather than reheated.
How do you keep the topping from going soggy?
The topping stays crisp when you separate it from the moist filling before reheating. Lift the cold mash off in one piece where you can, warm the filling in a pan, then return the mash and brown it under a grill. Adding a little grated cheese to the top helps it form a firm crust. Serve the pie straight from the oven so the steam does not soften the surface.
Can leftover fish pie be frozen?
Yes, a fish pie freezes well if the sauce is thick and the fish was fresh when the pie was made. Cool it fully, portion it into containers and freeze it on the day it was cooked. Thaw a portion in the refrigerator before reheating, then heat it covered until steaming. Potato topping can turn grainy after freezing, so a fresh mash layer is worth adding.
What can you make with the leftover filling?
Leftover fish pie filling becomes fish croquettes, a hash or a quick pasta sauce when the sauce is loose. Flake the fish, mix it with the cold sauce and bind it with breadcrumbs for croquettes. Fry it with cubed potato and onion for a hash that needs only a hot pan. A loose filling can also be warmed and spooned over rice or pasta.