What Is Menu Costing and How to Cost a Seafood Menu

Learn what menu costing means and how to cost a seafood menu: portion cost, recipe costing, food cost percentage and pricing each plate with confidence.

8 min read2 viewsWhat Is Menu Costing and How to Cost a Seafood Menu
— · 0 votes
Contents
  1. Menu costing in plain terms
  2. Set up a costing sheet
  3. Cost the edible portion of seafood
  4. Build the recipe costing up to the plate
  5. Turn plate cost into a menu price
  6. Read the food cost percentage correctly
  7. Use menu engineering on the results
  8. Keep a seafood menu costed through the year
  9. Questions About Costing a Seafood Menu
  10. What is menu costing?
  11. How do I cost a seafood menu when fish prices keep changing?
  12. Why is seafood portion cost higher than the purchase price per pound?
  13. What food cost percentage should a seafood dish aim for?
  14. How does menu engineering use plate cost?

Menu costing is the work of adding up what each dish costs you to make and setting a price that covers that cost and leaves a margin. For a seafood menu, costing starts with the edible portion of each fish or shellfish and builds up through the recipe to the plate. The result is a plate cost and a food cost percentage for every dish you sell.

  • Menu costing turns a recipe into a number: the cost of the ingredients on one plate.
  • Seafood costs shift with the market, so recheck fish and shellfish prices before you set a menu price.
  • Trim, shell and cooking loss mean you pay for more weight than the guest eats.
  • A food cost percentage compares the plate cost with the menu price and shows whether a dish earns its place.
  • Menu engineering uses those numbers to decide which dishes to keep, reprice or drop.

Menu costing in plain terms

Menu costing is the total of everything a single dish costs to produce, divided across the portions you sell. The figure includes the ingredients on the plate and the waste that came with preparing them. Labor and overhead sit outside the plate cost, though a fuller costing can add them.

The core number in menu costing is the plate cost, sometimes called the portion cost. A plate cost is the ingredient cost of one serving of a finished dish. Once you have that figure, you can compare it with the price you charge.

Menu costing is not a one-time task, because supplier prices move. A seafood menu needs a costing pass whenever fish prices change or a recipe changes. Keep the working sheet so you can update the numbers rather than start over.

Set up a costing sheet

A costing sheet lists every ingredient in a recipe with its purchase unit, its cost and the quantity the recipe uses. The sheet converts those quantities into a single plate cost. One sheet per dish keeps the work traceable when a price changes.

Start with the purchase cost of each item as you buy it, such as a whole fish or a bag of shellfish. Record the unit you buy in, because a cost per case and a cost per pound are not interchangeable. The sheet does the conversion, not your memory.

Add a line for trim and waste, then a line for the yield you actually get from each purchase. When the sheet is finished, the plate cost is the sum of the usable ingredient costs divided by the number of portions. Update the sheet when a supplier invoice changes.

  • List each ingredient with its purchase unit and cost
  • Note the trim, shell or bone loss for that item
  • Convert the recipe quantity to a cost
  • Add the costs of all ingredients on the plate
  • Divide by the number of portions the recipe yields
  • Record the date of the last price check

Cost the edible portion of seafood

Seafood is sold by weight, but part of that weight never reaches the plate. Bones, shells, skin, heads and trim are paid for and then removed. Edible portion costing prices only the part the guest eats.

A whole fish loses weight to filleting, and a live lobster loses weight to shell and head. The purchase price applies to the whole item, so the cost per edible ounce is higher than the cost per purchase pound. Recipe costing has to use the edible figure.

Weigh the trim once for each species you serve, and keep the yield figure on the costing sheet. Yields differ between species, between sizes and between suppliers, so a single blanket figure misleads. Recheck the yield when you change supplier or fish size.

Build the recipe costing up to the plate

Recipe costing adds the cost of every component on the plate, not only the fish. Sauces, starches, vegetables, garnishes and cooking liquids all carry a cost. A dish with a modest fillet and a rich sauce can cost more than the fish alone suggests.

Cost each component as its own small recipe, then combine them for the plate. A sauce used across several dishes is costed once and allocated by the portion served. This keeps the arithmetic consistent when one component changes.

Cooking loss belongs in the recipe costing, because a fillet shrinks as it cooks and a shellfish releases liquid. The portion you serve is the cooked weight, while the cost comes from the raw weight. Record both so the plate cost reflects what actually leaves the kitchen.

Turn plate cost into a menu price

A menu price is set from the plate cost plus the margin the business needs to cover labor, rent and profit. Seafood menu pricing uses the food cost percentage as the bridge between the two figures. The percentage is the plate cost divided by the menu price.

Target food cost percentages differ by dish type, and a dish with expensive seafood needs a different share than a simple starter. Decide the percentage you need for each part of the menu, then work back to a price. Round the price to a figure guests can read easily.

Seafood prices move faster than most ingredients, so leave room in the margin for market swings. A dish priced tightly to today's fish price becomes a loss when the boat price rises. Review the price when the supplier cost changes rather than absorbing it silently.

ItemFigure to record
Purchase cost of the seafoodCost per purchase unit
Edible yield after trim and shellPercentage of purchase weight
Cost of the edible portionCost per served portion
Other ingredients on the plateSum of component costs
Plate costTotal ingredient cost per serving
Food cost percentagePlate cost divided by menu price

Read the food cost percentage correctly

Food cost percentage expresses the plate cost as a share of the menu price, so a lower percentage means more margin. The number is a ratio, not a verdict, and it only makes sense against the price you set. Two dishes with the same percentage can carry very different cash margins.

A high-cost seafood dish can still be worth selling if its cash margin is strong. A low-cost dish with a small cash margin may contribute less than it appears. Read the percentage together with the money left after the plate cost.

Compare the percentage across the menu to spot dishes that drift as prices change. A dish whose percentage climbs above its target needs a price change, a portion change or a recipe change. The percentage is a signal to act, not a label to file away.

Use menu engineering on the results

Menu engineering sorts dishes by how much margin they earn and how well they sell. The costing data supplies the margin side, and sales records supply the volume side. Together they show which dishes deserve the menu space.

Dishes with strong margin and strong sales are the ones to protect and keep visible. Dishes with strong margin and weak sales may need a better description or a different place on the menu. Dishes with weak margin need repricing, a recipe change or removal.

Menu engineering works only when the plate costs are current, so refresh the seafood costs before each review. A review built on stale fish prices points you at the wrong dishes. Treat the costing sheet as the input and the menu decision as the output.

Keep a seafood menu costed through the year

A seafood menu needs a costing routine because supply and price change with the season. Set a schedule to check supplier invoices against the costing sheets. Any item that moved beyond your tolerance gets recosted and repriced.

Build flexibility into the menu so a price jump does not force a rushed decision. Dishes that share components let you swap a species without rebuilding the whole sheet. Keep a note of acceptable substitute fish for each dish.

Train the kitchen to record trim and portion weights so the yields on the sheet stay honest. A costing sheet is only as good as the weights behind it. Review the yields whenever a supplier or a fish size changes.

Questions About Costing a Seafood Menu

What is menu costing?

Menu costing is the process of calculating what each dish costs to make and using that figure to set a menu price. It adds the ingredient costs of one serving into a plate cost, then compares that cost with the price charged. The result is a food cost percentage for each dish.

How do I cost a seafood menu when fish prices keep changing?

Cost a seafood menu from current supplier prices and recheck the sheet whenever an invoice changes. Record the date of each price on the costing sheet so you know which figures are stale. Review the menu price when the fish cost moves beyond the margin you set.

Why is seafood portion cost higher than the purchase price per pound?

Seafood portion cost is higher because bones, shells, skin and trim are paid for but not served. The edible portion is a fraction of the purchase weight, so the cost per served ounce exceeds the cost per purchase pound. Weighing the trim for each species gives you the real yield.

What food cost percentage should a seafood dish aim for?

There is no single food cost percentage for a seafood dish, because the target depends on your labor, rent and profit needs. Set a target for each part of the menu and price back from the plate cost. Read the percentage alongside the cash margin the dish leaves.

How does menu engineering use plate cost?

Menu engineering combines plate cost with sales volume to sort dishes by margin and by how well they sell. The plate cost supplies the margin figure for each dish. The review then shows which dishes to keep, reprice or remove.

Latest articles