Scandinavian Fish Dishes for Home Cooking: From the Seafood Counter to the Table
How to cook Scandinavian fish dishes at home: choose salmon and herring at the seafood counter, cure gravlax, pickle herring, plan portions and make-ahead menus, and use Central European substitutes.
Contents
- What makes Scandinavian fish dishes different?
- Which Scandinavian fish dish suits which occasion?
- How to choose fish at the seafood counter for Scandinavian dishes
- Salmon for gravlax, soup and open sandwiches
- Herring: fresh, salted, matjes or ready-pickled?
- Other useful fish
- How do you make gravlax at home?
- Is homemade gravlax safe to eat?
- How do you pickle herring the Scandinavian way?
- Warm Scandinavian fish dishes for weeknights and winter
- Finnish salmon soup (lohikeitto)
- Jansson's temptation
- Fried herring and fish cakes
- How to plan a Scandinavian fish table
- How much fish per person?
- Make-ahead timeline for a gathering
- Sides and garnishes
- Drinks to serve
- Which Central European ingredients can replace Scandinavian ones?
- How to handle cured, smoked and pickled fish safely
The most practical Scandinavian fish dishes to cook at home are gravlax (salt-and-sugar cured salmon), pickled herring, creamy salmon soup, Jansson's temptation (a potato and sprat bake) and pan-fried herring or fish cakes. They use few ingredients: salt, sugar, vinegar, dill, cream, potatoes and rye bread. Several of them are made one to three days ahead, which makes them a good fit for gatherings. Most of the ingredients are easy to find in Central Europe, where herring, salmon and festive fish menus are already familiar.
What makes Scandinavian fish dishes different?
Scandinavian fish cooking is built on preservation. Salting, curing, pickling and smoking were developed to keep the catch through long winters. The result is a cuisine of contrasts:
- Cold, cured fish is served next to warm potatoes.
- Sharp vinegar brines are balanced with sweetness.
- Rich salmon is paired with dill, mustard and dark rye bread.
Central European cooks will recognise much of this from rollmops, Bismarck herring and matjes. The Swedish, Norwegian, Danish and Finnish versions tend to be sweeter, use more dill and allspice, and are served as part of a shared table.
Which Scandinavian fish dish suits which occasion?
Choose a dish by how much time you have and whether you want to cook ahead or serve straight from the stove. Use the table below to compare them.
| Dish | Main fish | Flavor and texture | Hands-on effort | Make-ahead | Best occasion |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gravlax | Salmon (or trout) | Silky, lightly salty-sweet, fresh dill | Low; mostly waiting | Must be made 2–3 days ahead | Festive starter, buffet, brunch |
| Pickled herring (inlagd sill) | Salted or matjes herring | Firm, sweet-sour, aromatic | Low | Best made 1–3 days ahead | Buffet, Christmas, Midsummer table |
| Mustard herring (senapssill) | Salted or matjes herring | Creamy, sweet, mustard-sharp | Low | Best made 1 day ahead | Buffet alongside plain pickled herring |
| Salmon soup (lohikeitto) | Salmon | Mild, creamy, tender fish and potato | Medium; about 40 minutes | Base ahead, fish added at the end | Weeknight, informal winter dinner |
| Jansson's temptation | Swedish spiced sprats (ansjovis) | Rich, creamy, salty-sweet | Medium; about 1 hour in the oven | Assemble ahead, bake before serving | Christmas buffet, cold-weather supper |
| Fried herring (stekt strömming) | Fresh small herring | Crisp outside, soft inside | Medium; cooked to order | Not ideal | Casual weeknight |
| Fish cakes (fiskefrikadeller) | Cod, pollock or other white fish | Light, tender, golden crust | Medium | Mix ahead, fry before serving | Family dinner, open sandwiches |
How to choose fish at the seafood counter for Scandinavian dishes
Buy the fish according to how it will be eaten. Fish for curing or eating raw needs the strictest freshness and handling. Fish for soups and fish cakes can come from cheaper cuts.
Salmon for gravlax, soup and open sandwiches
For gravlax, choose a skin-on, centre-cut salmon fillet of even thickness. Ask the fishmonger to remove the pin bones. Even thickness matters because the thin tail end cures faster and becomes saltier. Look for these signs of freshness:
- Firm, moist flesh that springs back when pressed
- Bright, even colour
- A clean sea smell rather than a fishy one
For soup, tail pieces and trimmings work well and usually cost less. Rainbow trout and sea trout are good, often cheaper alternatives for both gravlax and soup.
Herring: fresh, salted, matjes or ready-pickled?
For home pickling, start with salted herring fillets or matjes rather than fresh raw herring.
- Salted herring is firm and very salty. Soak it in cold water before use.
- Matjes are young, mildly cured herring. They are soft, rich and usually ready to use.
- Ready-pickled herring from a good producer is a sensible shortcut. You can drain it and dress it in your own mustard or cream sauce.
Fresh small herring is ideal for frying, but it is less common at inland Central European counters.
Other useful fish
- Cod, pollock and haddock suit fish cakes, Norwegian-style creamy fish soup and baked dishes.
- Plaice is used for fried fillets on Danish open sandwiches.
- Cooked, peeled prawns make a quick shrimp salad with mayonnaise, crème fraîche and dill for rye toast.
- Cold- and hot-smoked salmon fill out a buffet without extra cooking. Cold-smoked salmon is silky. Hot-smoked salmon is flaky and fully cooked.
How do you make gravlax at home?
Gravlax is raw salmon cured under a mixture of salt, sugar and dill for about two to three days in the refrigerator. It is not cooked or smoked. The salt firms the flesh and draws out moisture, while the sugar softens the saltiness.
- Prepare the salmon. Start with about 1 kg of skin-on, pin-boned centre-cut fillet that is suitable for raw consumption (see the safety note below). Pat it dry. Cut it into two equal pieces if you want to sandwich it.
- Mix the cure. Combine equal weights of coarse salt and sugar. A common starting point is around 50–60 g of each per 1 kg of fillet, plus a teaspoon of crushed white pepper. Some cooks use a little more salt for a firmer result.
- Add the dill. Chop a large bunch of dill, stalks included. Spread some in a non-metallic dish.
- Layer the fish. Place one piece of salmon skin-side down. Cover it with the cure and most of the dill. Put the second piece on top, flesh to flesh. If you are curing a single piece, cover only the flesh side.
- Cover and weigh. Wrap tightly. Place a light weight on top, such as a plate with a couple of cans.
- Cure in the fridge. Refrigerate for 48–72 hours. Turn the fish about every 12 hours and baste it with the liquid that collects. Longer curing gives a firmer, saltier result.
- Finish and slice. Scrape off the cure and pat the fish dry. Cover it with fresh chopped dill if you like. Slice thinly on a slant, cutting the flesh away from the skin.
Serve gravlax with hovmästarsås, a mustard-dill sauce. Whisk sweet Swedish-style or mild mustard with a little Dijon, sugar and vinegar. Slowly whisk in neutral oil until thick, then stir in plenty of chopped dill. Boiled new potatoes, rye bread or crispbread, and lemon complete the plate.
Is homemade gravlax safe to eat?
Curing does not reliably kill parasites, so salmon for gravlax should be frozen first or bought already frozen for raw consumption.
- Food-safety guidance in many countries calls for freezing fish intended for raw eating at −20 °C or colder for a set period.
- Home freezers often run at around −18 °C, so freezing for longer (several days to a week) is the cautious choice.
- The simplest route is to ask the fishmonger for salmon labelled or confirmed as suitable for raw use.
Thaw frozen salmon slowly in the refrigerator before curing.
How do you pickle herring the Scandinavian way?
Swedish pickled herring (inlagd sill) is salted herring layered in a cold, sweet vinegar brine with onion and spices. It is ready after one to two days in the refrigerator. The classic brine follows a 1-2-3 ratio by volume: 1 part 12% vinegar (Swedish ättika), 2 parts sugar and 3 parts water.
- Desalt the herring if needed. Soak salted herring fillets in plenty of cold water in the fridge for several hours or overnight, changing the water once or twice. Taste a small piece; it should be pleasantly salty, not harsh. Matjes usually need no soaking.
- Make the brine. Heat the sugar and water until the sugar dissolves. Let it cool completely, then add the vinegar.
- Add the aromatics. Use sliced red onion, thin carrot slices, a few allspice berries, a bay leaf and optionally a little dill. Some versions add mustard seeds or a slice of fresh ginger.
- Layer the jar. Cut the herring into bite-sized pieces. Layer them in a clean jar with the aromatics.
- Pickle in the fridge. Pour the cold brine over the fish so it is fully covered. Seal the jar and refrigerate for at least one day, ideally two, before serving.
Adjusting for Central European vinegar. Spirit vinegars sold in Central Europe are usually weaker than ättika; check the acidity on the label. To keep the same total sourness, use more vinegar and less water:
- With 8% vinegar: about 1.5 parts vinegar to 2.5 parts water
- With 10% vinegar: about 1.2 parts vinegar to 2.8 parts water
Vinegar essence is much stronger and must be diluted accordingly.
For mustard herring, dress drained herring pieces in a sauce of sweet mustard, a little vinegar, sugar, oil, a spoon of cream or crème fraîche and chopped dill.
If you pickle fresh raw herring instead of salted fish, freeze it first, as you would salmon for gravlax.
Warm Scandinavian fish dishes for weeknights and winter
Not every Scandinavian fish dish is cured. These warm dishes are suited to ordinary evenings and cold weather.
Finnish salmon soup (lohikeitto)
Lohikeitto is a mild, creamy soup of salmon, potatoes and dill.
- Soften leek or onion in butter.
- Add diced potatoes, fish or vegetable stock, a few allspice berries and a bay leaf. Simmer until the potatoes are tender.
- Stir in cream.
- Add cubes of skinless salmon and poach very gently for only a few minutes, until just opaque.
- Finish with plenty of dill.
The potato base can be made hours ahead. Add the salmon only when reheating, so it stays tender.
Jansson's temptation
Jansson's temptation is a Swedish gratin of potato matchsticks, onion and cream, layered with Swedish ansjovis. These are sprats cured in a sweet, spiced brine, not Italian salted anchovies.
- Layer the potatoes, softened onion and sprats in a buttered dish.
- Pour over cream and some of the sprat brine, and top with breadcrumbs and butter.
- Bake in a hot oven until the potatoes are tender and the top is golden, usually close to an hour.
If Swedish ansjovis are unavailable, Baltic spiced sprats sold in Central European shops are the closest match. Italian anchovies are saltier and lack the sweet spice, so use fewer of them.
Fried herring and fish cakes
Stekt strömming is made from fresh small herring fillets. Sandwich them in pairs with dill, dredge them in rye flour and fry them in butter until crisp. Serve with mashed potatoes and lingonberry or cranberry preserve.
Danish fiskefrikadeller are fish cakes made from minced white fish, onion, egg, a little flour and milk. Shape them with a spoon and fry them in butter. Serve them warm with remoulade, or cold on buttered rye bread.
How to plan a Scandinavian fish table
A Scandinavian fish table works best as a mix of cold cured dishes made in advance and one or two warm dishes finished at the last minute. Serve it in courses: herring first, then salmon, then warm dishes.
How much fish per person?
- Main course: a common rule of thumb is 150–200 g of raw fish fillet per person.
- Buffet with several fish dishes: plan smaller amounts of each. Roughly 50–80 g of each cured fish per person is a reasonable starting point.
- Potatoes and bread: make plenty. Cured fish is rich and salty and eaten in small bites, so guests fill up on the sides.
- Gravlax yield: a 1 kg fillet loses some weight during curing and trimming. It comfortably serves a group as one of several starters.
Make-ahead timeline for a gathering
- About a week before: buy and freeze salmon or fresh herring for raw use, or order fish already frozen for raw consumption.
- 3 days before: thaw the salmon in the fridge and start the gravlax.
- 2 days before: soak salted herring if using it, then make the pickled herring.
- 1 day before: make the mustard herring and the mustard-dill sauce. Prepare the soup base or assemble Jansson's temptation, covered in the fridge.
- On the day: slice the gravlax, boil the new potatoes, bake or finish the warm dish, and set out the bread, butter and garnishes.
Sides and garnishes
- Boiled new or waxy potatoes with butter and dill
- Dark rye bread, crispbread and good butter
- Hard-boiled eggs, chives, red onion, capers
- Sour cream or crème fraîche
- Quick-pickled cucumber and beetroot salad, both familiar in Central European kitchens
- A strong cheese such as aged hard cheese, which is traditional on Swedish tables
Drinks to serve
- Cold beer: pale lager is a classic match for herring and salmon.
- Aquavit: caraway- or dill-flavoured aquavit is the traditional choice for festive tables, served very cold in small glasses.
- White wine: crisp, dry wines such as Riesling or Grüner Veltliner suit cured salmon and creamy soups.
- Non-alcoholic: sparkling water with lemon, or apple juice, works well with the sweet-sour flavours.
Which Central European ingredients can replace Scandinavian ones?
Most Scandinavian fish dishes adapt well to ingredients found in Central European shops.
| Scandinavian ingredient | Practical substitute | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Swedish ättika (12% vinegar) | Local spirit vinegar | Check the acidity and adjust the vinegar-to-water ratio |
| Swedish ansjovis | Baltic spiced sprats | Italian anchovies are saltier; use fewer |
| Sweet Swedish mustard | Mild mustard plus a little honey or sugar | Add Dijon for sharpness |
| Salmon for gravlax | Rainbow trout or sea trout | Thinner fillets need a shorter cure |
| Baltic herring for frying | Small fresh herring or sprats | Larger fish need longer frying |
| Swedish crispbread | Dark rye or wholegrain crispbread, or toasted rye bread | Choose a dense, lightly sour rye |
| Lingonberry preserve | Cranberry preserve | Similar tart-sweet balance |
How to handle cured, smoked and pickled fish safely
Cured, cold-smoked and pickled fish are not cooked, so cold storage and clean handling matter more than with cooked fish.
- Keep everything cold. Store fish in the coldest part of the refrigerator. Do not leave cured fish at room temperature on a buffet for long periods. Put out small portions and refill them from the fridge.
- Use clean equipment. Use clean jars, dishes and utensils. Take herring from the jar with a clean fork rather than fingers.
- Keep fish covered. Pickled herring should stay fully covered by brine.
- Eat within a few days. Homemade gravlax and pickled herring are best eaten within a few days of being ready. Follow the use-by dates on commercial products once opened.
- Protect vulnerable guests. People who are pregnant, elderly or have weakened immunity are commonly advised to avoid cold-smoked and raw cured fish because of the risk of listeria. Offer cooked options such as salmon soup, fish cakes, hot-smoked salmon or Jansson's temptation.
- Freeze before raw use. Any fish you cure or pickle from raw should be frozen as described above, unless it was supplied ready for raw consumption.
With one cured dish, one pickled dish and one warm dish, plus good bread, potatoes and dill, Scandinavian fish dishes make a generous table. Most of the work is done before your guests arrive.