Rick Stein Herring Recipes: Mastering a British Coastal Classic

Explore Rick Stein's approach to herring recipes, from traditional rollmops to modern grilled dishes. Learn how to select, prepare, and serve herring with confidence, including portion sizes, pairings, and make-ahead tips.

4 min readSardines, Mackerel & Herring10 viewsRick Stein Herring Recipes: Mastering a British Coastal Classic
— · 0 votes
Contents
  1. Why Rick Stein Champions Herring
  2. Selecting Herring at the Seafood Counter
  3. Essential Rick Stein Herring Recipes
  4. 1. Grilled Herring with Mustard Butter
  5. 2. Herring in Oatmeal (Traditional Scottish Style)
  6. 3. Rollmops (Pickled Herring)
  7. 4. Herring with Lemon and Black Pepper
  8. Flavour and Texture Comparisons
  9. Portions and Planning a Herring-Centred Table
  10. Pairings and Substitutions
  11. Safe Handling and Make-Ahead Tips

Rick Stein’s herring recipes celebrate this often-overlooked fish with simple, bold flavours rooted in British coastal traditions. From quick pan-fried fillets with oats to Scandinavian-inspired pickled herring, his approach makes herring accessible for weeknight dinners or special gatherings. The key is balancing herring’s rich, oily texture with sharp, acidic or sweet accompaniments. Below, we break down his most practical recipes, preparation techniques, and serving ideas so you can choose confidently at the seafood counter.

Why Rick Stein Champions Herring

Rick Stein has long advocated for underused British fish, and herring is a prime example. He often features it in his cookbooks and TV programmes, praising its affordability, sustainability, and deep flavour. Herring is an oily fish, similar to mackerel but with a finer, softer flake. Stein’s recipes typically use simple methods—grilling, frying, or pickling—that let the fish’s natural richness shine while cutting through it with vinegar, citrus, or sharp onions.

Selecting Herring at the Seafood Counter

Fresh herring should have bright, clear eyes, shiny skin, and a clean sea smell. Look for fish that feel firm and spring back when pressed. Whole herring are usually 200–300g each; allow one fish per person for a main course, or two smaller fillets. If buying fillets, check they are moist but not mushy, with no brown patches. Frozen herring is a good option—thaw overnight in the fridge and pat dry before cooking.

Essential Rick Stein Herring Recipes

1. Grilled Herring with Mustard Butter

Stein’s version of grilled herring is simple: slash the skin, brush with oil, and cook under a hot grill or on a barbecue for 4–5 minutes per side. Serve with a mustard butter made by mixing softened butter, Dijon mustard, lemon juice, and chopped parsley. The mustard’s heat balances the fish’s oiliness.

2. Herring in Oatmeal (Traditional Scottish Style)

This recipe dips herring fillets in seasoned oatmeal and fries them in butter or bacon fat until crisp. Stein often pairs this with a sharp gooseberry or rhubarb sauce, echoing the Scottish tradition of pairing oily fish with tart fruit.

3. Rollmops (Pickled Herring)

Stein’s rollmops recipe involves curing herring fillets in a brine of salt and sugar for a few hours, then rolling them around onion, gherkin, and sometimes a caper. The rolls are packed in a jar and covered with a spiced vinegar solution (vinegar, water, sugar, peppercorns, bay leaf, and mustard seeds). They keep for up to two weeks in the fridge and are perfect for buffets.

4. Herring with Lemon and Black Pepper

A quick weeknight option: season fillets, dust with flour, and pan-fry in olive oil until golden. Finish with a generous squeeze of lemon and cracked black pepper. Stein suggests serving with new potatoes and a green salad.

Flavour and Texture Comparisons

PreparationFlavour ProfileTextureBest Occasion
Grilled with mustard butterSmoky, tangy, richCrisp skin, moist flakeCasual barbecue or dinner
Fried in oatmealNutty, savoury, slightly sweetCrunchy crust, tender interiorBrunch or hearty lunch
Rollmops (pickled)Sharp, sweet-sour, spicedFirm, slightly chewyAppetiser, buffet, or snack
Pan-fried with lemonClean, buttery, citrusySoft, delicate flakesQuick weeknight meal

Portions and Planning a Herring-Centred Table

For a main course, plan on 150–200g of herring fillet per person (about 2 medium fillets). If serving whole fish, one 250g fish per person is sufficient. Herring is rich, so balance the meal with light sides: boiled new potatoes, cucumber salad, beetroot, or rye bread. For a buffet, rollmops are excellent; expect each guest to eat 2–3 rolls.

When planning a menu, consider the cooking method. Grilled or fried herring is best cooked à la minute, while pickled herring can be made days ahead. If you choose pan-fried recipes, prep the fish and sides before guests arrive, then cook the fish in batches and keep warm in a low oven. Herring skin can smoke when grilled, so ensure good ventilation if cooking indoors.

Pairings and Substitutions

Classic pairings for herring include:

  • Acidic elements: lemon, vinegar, pickled onions, capers, or tart fruit sauces (gooseberry, rhubarb, apple).
  • Starchy sides: rye bread, boiled potatoes, or oatcakes.
  • Dairy: sour cream, crème fraîche, or butter-based sauces.

If herring is unavailable, mackerel or fresh sardines can be substituted in most recipes. Mackerel has a firmer texture and stronger flavour, so reduce cooking time slightly. Sardines are smaller and more delicate; adjust portions to two fish per person. For pickling, mackerel also works well, though the fillets are larger and may need longer curing.

Safe Handling and Make-Ahead Tips

Fresh herring should be cooked or frozen within 24 hours of purchase. Keep it on ice in the fridge until ready to use. When curing or pickling, always use a non-reactive container (glass or ceramic) and keep the fish submerged in the brine. Pickled herring without preservatives should be consumed within two weeks and refrigerated at all times.

Make-ahead options:

  • Rollmops: prepare up to 2 weeks ahead; flavour improves after 2–3 days.
  • Mustard butter: can be made a week ahead and refrigerated; soften before serving.
  • Oatmeal coating: mix dry ingredients and store in an airtight container; coat fish just before frying.
  • Brined herring for pickling: you can brine the fillets a day ahead, then drain and pack in vinegar solution.

By following Rick Stein’s straightforward methods and these practical tips, herring can become a regular, rewarding part of your cooking repertoire—whether for a quick supper or a celebratory coastal feast.

Related articles

  • BBC Herring Recipes and How to Cook Herring the BBC Way

    BBC Herring Recipes and How to Cook Herring the BBC Way

    Learn how to cook herring using BBC-inspired recipes and techniques. Discover the best ways to prepare fresh, pickled, and smoked herring, with step-by-step instructions, flavor pairings, and serving ideas.

  • Oven-Baked Herring Recipes: From Seafood Counter to a Table Worth Gathering Around

    Oven-Baked Herring Recipes: From Seafood Counter to a Table Worth Gathering Around

    Learn how to bake whole herring in the oven with step-by-step guidance, seasoning ideas, and serving suggestions. Discover tips on choosing fresh herring, how roasting affects its rich flavor, and what to serve alongside for a satisfying meal.

  • Canned Herring Recipes

    Canned Herring Recipes

    Discover how to turn canned herring into easy, flavorful meals. From toast to salads, learn cooking tips, flavor differences, and practical recipe ideas.

  • Pan-Fried Herring Recipes: Crispy Skin and Tender Flesh

    Pan-Fried Herring Recipes: Crispy Skin and Tender Flesh

    Learn how to pan-fry herring fillets with crispy skin and tender flesh. Includes step-by-step instructions, seasoning ideas, serving suggestions, and tips for choosing and handling herring.

  • Herring Recipes and Easy Meal Ideas

    Herring Recipes and Easy Meal Ideas

    Discover the best herring recipes UK style, from pan-fried fresh herring to marinated fillets and traditional British fish dishes. Learn flavor, texture, preparation, and serving tips for Sardines, Mackerel & Herring.