Pickled and Marinated Herring Recipes for the Home Table
How to choose herring at the seafood counter, pickle it safely, and make Scandinavian and UK classics such as 1-2-3 herring, mustard herring, rollmops and soused herring, plus portions, pairings and make-ahead plans.
Contents
- What is the difference between pickled and marinated herring?
- Which herring should you buy at the seafood counter?
- How do you handle herring safely before pickling?
- Safe handling checklist
- How do you make a basic pickled herring recipe?
- Ingredients (about 4 to 6 servings as part of a spread)
- Steps
- Which pickled herring recipes are Scandinavian classics?
- 1-2-3 pickled herring (inlagd sill)
- Glassmästarsill (glassblower's herring)
- Mustard herring (senapssill)
- Herring in sour cream or crème fraîche
- Which pickled herring recipes are traditional in the UK?
- Rollmops
- Bismarck herring
- Baked soused herring
- How do the main herring styles compare?
- How much herring should you plan per person?
- What are the best serving ideas and pairings for pickled herring?
- Building a herring table worth gathering around
- How far ahead can you make pickled and marinated herring?
- What substitutions work in herring recipes?
- How do you choose the right herring recipe for your occasion?
Pickled herring is herring cured in an acidic vinegar marinade, usually with sugar, onions and pickling spices. Marinated herring is a broader term that also covers dressings such as mustard, sour cream, tomato or curry. Most home cooks start from salt-cured herring fillets or from plain jarred pickled herring, then add their own brine or sauce. Fresh raw herring can also be pickled, but it must be frozen first to kill parasites. Scandinavian recipes tend to be sweet and spiced. British recipes are sharper, and they include rollmops and baked soused herring. Vinegar-pickled herring is best made 1 to 3 days ahead, which makes it a practical centrepiece for a gathering.
What is the difference between pickled and marinated herring?
Pickled herring is defined by its acid. The fish sits in vinegar, often sweetened, until the flesh turns opaque and firm. Marinated herring is the umbrella term. It includes pickled herring, and it also covers herring that is first pickled or salt-cured and then folded into a richer sauce.
- Pickled herring: herring fillets in a vinegar, sugar and water brine with onions and whole spices. It tastes clean, sharp or sweet-sour, and the texture is firm.
- Marinated herring in a sauce: pickled or desalted herring served in mustard-dill, sour cream, crème fraîche, tomato or curry dressing. It tastes rounder and softer, with a shorter fridge life once dairy is added.
- Baked soused herring (UK): herring cooked in a spiced vinegar liquor and then cooled in it. The texture is tender and flaky rather than firm.
The Dutch also use the word soused herring for maatjes, a mild, lightly cured raw herring. It is not vinegar-pickled. Check which style a recipe means before you shop.
Which herring should you buy at the seafood counter?
Your choice of herring sets your prep time. Salt-cured fillets and plain jarred pickled herring are the quickest routes to good results. Fresh whole herring is cheapest and most flexible, but it needs filleting, freezing and curing.
| Starting point | Prep needed | Best for | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fresh whole herring | Fillet, freeze, brine, then pickle | Rollmops, baked soused herring, fully homemade pickled herring | Look for bright eyes, shiny skin and a clean sea smell. Baking removes the need for parasite freezing. |
| Frozen herring fillets | Thaw in the fridge, brine, then pickle | Rollmops and vinegar pickles | Convenient. Check whether they were frozen long enough for raw use. |
| Salt-cured herring (whole or fillets) | Soak to remove salt, then pickle | Scandinavian 1-2-3 herring, glassmästarsill | Traditional base for Nordic recipes. Gives a firm, meaty texture. |
| Plain jarred pickled herring | Drain only | Mustard, cream, curry or tomato marinated herring | Fastest option. Choose an unflavoured jar so your sauce defines the flavour. |
| Matjes / maatjes herring | None, or a short rinse | Serving plain with onion, potatoes and sour cream | Mild and soft. It is not a vinegar pickle, so treat it as its own style. |
How do you handle herring safely before pickling?
Raw herring can carry parasites that vinegar does not reliably kill, so fresh fish intended for raw pickling must be frozen first. Freezing guidance varies by country. Commonly cited food-safety advice includes freezing at −20°C (−4°F) or colder for 7 days. Domestic freezers do not always hold that temperature, so check yours with a thermometer. Alternatively, buy fish that the supplier confirms has been frozen for raw consumption. Salt-cured herring and commercially pickled herring have already been processed. Baked soused herring is cooked through.
Safe handling checklist
- Keep fresh herring cold and use it within a day of purchase, or freeze it straight away.
- Thaw frozen herring in the fridge, never on the counter.
- Soak salt-cured herring in cold water in the fridge, usually overnight to 24 hours. Change the water several times and taste a small piece to judge the saltiness.
- Pickle in glass, ceramic or food-safe plastic, not reactive metal.
- Keep pickled and marinated herring refrigerated and covered by its liquid or sauce.
- Eat homemade vinegar-pickled herring within about a week. Eat herring in cream or sour-cream dressings within 2 to 3 days. For shop-bought jars, follow the label once opened.
- Use a clean fork to serve, and do not return leftovers from the table to the jar.
How do you make a basic pickled herring recipe?
A basic pickled herring is made by pouring a cooled, sweetened vinegar marinade over herring pieces, onions and pickling spices, then refrigerating for at least 24 hours. This method works with desalted salt herring, or with fresh fillets that have been frozen and briefly brined.
Ingredients (about 4 to 6 servings as part of a spread)
- 400–500 g herring fillets, desalted or prepared as described below
- 1 red or yellow onion, thinly sliced
- Pickling spices: 1 tsp allspice berries, 1 tsp mustard seeds, 2 bay leaves, a few black peppercorns. Add a few cloves if you like.
- Vinegar marinade: see the Scandinavian 1-2-3 ratio below, or use 250 ml white wine or cider vinegar (about 5% acidity), 150 ml water and 75–100 g sugar
Steps
- Prepare the fish. For salt herring, soak it as described above. For fresh fillets that have been frozen and thawed, cover them in cold salted water (roughly 100 g salt per litre) for 2 to 3 hours in the fridge, then rinse.
- Make the marinade. Heat the vinegar, water, sugar and spices until the sugar dissolves. Let it cool completely, because hot liquid will cook the fish unevenly.
- Cut and layer. Pat the fillets dry, slice them into 2–3 cm pieces, and layer them in a jar with the onion and spices.
- Cover and chill. Pour over the cold marinade until the fish is submerged. Seal the jar and refrigerate it.
- Wait. The herring can be eaten after 24 hours. Most cooks find the flavour and texture best after 2 to 3 days.
Which pickled herring recipes are Scandinavian classics?
Scandinavian pickled herring recipes are typically sweet-sour, built on salt-cured herring and a sugar-rich brine, and served in several styles side by side. At Swedish midsummer, Christmas and Easter tables, plain pickled herring usually appears alongside mustard herring and a cream-based herring.
1-2-3 pickled herring (inlagd sill)
The Swedish 1-2-3 brine uses 1 part ättika (12% spirit vinegar), 2 parts sugar and 3 parts water by volume, for example 1 dl, 2 dl and 3 dl. Dissolve the sugar in the warm liquid, cool the brine, then pour it over desalted herring with red onion, allspice and bay. If you only have 5% vinegar, use about 2.5 times the volume of ättika and reduce the water by the same extra amount. That keeps the acidity close to the original.
Glassmästarsill (glassblower's herring)
This version uses the same 1-2-3 brine, poured over herring pieces layered with sliced carrot, red onion, fresh horseradish, allspice, bay and mustard seeds. The vegetables make the jar look striking on the table and add crunch. Allow 2 to 3 days in the fridge.
Mustard herring (senapssill)
Whisk sweet Swedish-style mustard with a little Dijon, sugar, vinegar and a neutral oil until thick, then fold in plenty of chopped dill. Stir in drained pickled herring. It can be served after a few hours, and it tastes better the next day.
Herring in sour cream or crème fraîche
Fold drained pickled herring into sour cream or crème fraîche, with a little mayonnaise if you like. Add chives, red onion and dill. Some cooks add diced apple or pickled beetroot. Because this version contains dairy, make it no more than a day ahead.
Which pickled herring recipes are traditional in the UK?
UK pickled herring recipes lean sharper and less sweet than Scandinavian ones. The best known are rollmops, Bismarck herring and baked soused herring.
Rollmops
Rollmops are raw herring fillets that are brined, rolled around sliced onion and a piece of gherkin, secured with a cocktail stick, and covered in spiced vinegar.
- Use fillets that have been frozen as described in the safety section, then brine them in salted water for 2 to 3 hours and rinse.
- Lay each fillet skin-side down. Add sliced onion and a strip of gherkin, roll from the tail end and secure with a stick.
- Pack the rolls into a jar. Cover them with cooled spiced vinegar, using less sugar than in Nordic brines.
- Refrigerate for 3 to 5 days before eating, so the vinegar can firm the fish through.
Bismarck herring
Bismarck herring are flat, unrolled fillets pickled in the same sharp spiced vinegar with onion. They are convenient for slicing onto bread.
Baked soused herring
Soused herring in the British sense is cooked, not raw.
- Roll or fold cleaned herring fillets and pack them snugly into an ovenproof dish.
- Scatter over sliced onion, bay leaves, peppercorns, allspice and a pinch of sugar.
- Pour over roughly equal parts vinegar and water until the fish is just covered.
- Cover and bake in a low oven (about 150–160°C) until the fish is cooked through and flakes easily. This usually takes 45 minutes to 1 hour, depending on size.
- Let the fish cool in its liquor, then chill it. Serve it cold with brown bread and butter or a crisp salad.
Because the fish is cooked, baked soused herring is a good choice when you cannot confirm that fresh herring was frozen for raw use. Mackerel can be cooked the same way.
How do the main herring styles compare?
| Style | Flavour | Texture | Earliest serving | Fridge life (homemade) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1-2-3 pickled herring | Sweet-sour, allspice | Firm | 1 day, best at 2–3 days | About 1 week |
| Glassmästarsill | Sweet-sour, horseradish heat | Firm, with crunchy vegetables | 2–3 days | About 1 week |
| Mustard herring | Sweet, tangy, dill | Firm fish in a thick sauce | A few hours | A few days |
| Herring in sour cream | Mild, creamy, fresh herbs | Soft | 1 hour | 2–3 days |
| Rollmops | Sharp, tangy, onion | Firm and springy | 3–5 days | About 1 week |
| Baked soused herring | Mellow vinegar, spiced | Tender, flaky | Once chilled | A few days |
How much herring should you plan per person?
Plan by role on the menu. When herring is one of several dishes on a buffet or smörgåsbord, a couple of pieces per style per person is usually enough. In that case, offering three styles matters more than making large batches of one. When herring is the main dish, served with potatoes and bread, plan for a fuller fillet or two per person. Make a little extra of the plain pickled style, because it keeps longest and is easy to reuse in salads or on open sandwiches.
What are the best serving ideas and pairings for pickled herring?
Pickled herring is traditionally served cold with something starchy, something creamy and something fresh to balance its acidity.
- Starch: boiled new potatoes with dill, dark rye bread, crispbread, or buttered brown bread for UK styles.
- Creamy: sour cream or crème fraîche with chives, butter, and halved hard-boiled eggs.
- Fresh and sharp: thinly sliced red onion, chopped dill, pickled beetroot, cucumber salad, apple.
- Cheese: a mature hard cheese, which is common on Swedish tables.
- Drinks: cold lager or pilsner, aquavit or snaps for Scandinavian occasions, a dry crisp white wine, or sparkling water with lemon.
Building a herring table worth gathering around
- Choose three contrasting styles: one clear vinegar pickle, one mustard herring and one creamy herring.
- Serve each in its own small bowl or jar with a separate fork, so the flavours do not mix.
- Put warm boiled potatoes, bread and condiments in the centre so guests can build their own plates.
- Add one warm dish, such as a potato gratin or meatballs, if the herring is the start of a longer meal.
- Keep the herring chilled until shortly before serving, and return it to the fridge after the meal.
How far ahead can you make pickled and marinated herring?
Vinegar-based pickled herring benefits from being made ahead. Cream-based marinated herring should be made close to serving. A practical timeline for a weekend gathering looks like this:
- 4–5 days before: start the rollmops, and begin soaking any salt herring.
- 2–3 days before: make the 1-2-3 herring and the glassmästarsill.
- 1 day before: make the mustard herring and bake any soused herring.
- On the day: fold the creamy herring, boil the potatoes, chop the herbs and slice the onions.
If time is short, start from plain jarred pickled herring. Mustard herring and sour cream herring can then be ready in under an hour.
What substitutions work in herring recipes?
Most marinated herring recipes adapt well to changes in fish, vinegar and sweetener, as long as you keep the acidity high enough and the fish cold.
- Fish: sprats or small mackerel work in baked soused recipes. Mackerel is richer and needs slightly longer cooking.
- Vinegar: white wine, cider and distilled vinegar all work. Malt vinegar gives a stronger British flavour. Avoid replacing vinegar with lemon juice in long-keeping pickles.
- Sugar: you can reduce the sugar for a sharper, UK-style taste. Removing it entirely makes Scandinavian recipes taste harsh.
- Dairy: Greek yoghurt can replace sour cream for a lighter sauce, though it will taste tangier.
- Spices: allspice, bay and mustard seed are the core. Dill seed, coriander seed, juniper or a strip of orange peel give a different character.
How do you choose the right herring recipe for your occasion?
Match the recipe to your time, budget and guests. For a quick, low-effort spread, buy plain jarred pickled herring and dress it two ways. For a festive Scandinavian table, plan 2 to 3 days ahead and make 1-2-3 herring, mustard herring and a creamy herring. For a British-style lunch, or when you have fresh herring that has not been frozen, bake soused herring. For the most budget-friendly option with hands-on satisfaction, fillet fresh herring, freeze it, and make rollmops. Whichever route you choose, keep the fish cold, give vinegar pickles time to mature, and serve the herring with potatoes, bread and fresh herbs.
Related articles
Jamie Oliver Pickled Herring Recipes: A Guide to Pickled Seafood & Escabeche
Explore Jamie Oliver's approach to pickled herring, from classic Scandinavian-style marinades to quick escabeche twists, with practical menu ideas, flavor comparisons, and serving tips for pickled seafood.