Mixed Seafood Grill at RPM Seafood: Ordering It and Cooking It at Home
How to approach a mixed seafood grill at RPM Seafood, plus how to build your own at home: choosing seafood, portions, grill times, sauces, pairings, safe handling and make-ahead tips.
Contents
- What is a mixed seafood grill at RPM Seafood?
- How do you make a mixed seafood grill the centerpiece of a shared meal?
- How do you choose seafood at the counter for a home mixed grill?
- What to look for at the seafood counter
- How much seafood do you need per person?
- How do you grill mixed seafood at home step by step?
- What sauces, sides and drinks go with a mixed seafood grill?
- Sauces
- Sides
- Drinks
- What can you substitute to fit your budget or availability?
- How do you handle seafood safely for a grill night?
- What can you make ahead for a mixed seafood grill?
- Should you serve a mixed seafood grill on one platter or plated?
A mixed seafood grill at RPM Seafood is an assortment of fish and shellfish cooked over high heat and served together. The appeal is variety. You get firm, meaty fish next to sweet, tender shellfish on one platter. RPM Seafood updates its seafood menu, so the exact items, portion and price of any mixed grill can change. Ask your server what is included before you order. If you want the same experience at home, choose three or four seafoods with different textures. Plan about 6–8 oz (170–225 g) of edible seafood per person for a main course. Then grill each item to its own doneness instead of cooking everything for the same time.
What is a mixed seafood grill at RPM Seafood?
A mixed seafood grill is a combination plate or platter of several grilled seafoods, usually finished with olive oil, citrus or a sauce. A mixed grill at a seafood restaurant like RPM Seafood usually combines one or two firm fish with shellfish such as shrimp, scallops or lobster, and sometimes octopus or squid. Restaurants change the specific components with the season and with supply, so this article describes how to evaluate the dish rather than listing a fixed recipe.
Questions worth asking before you order:
- Which items are included today? Market availability decides which fish appear.
- Is it sized for one person or for sharing? This tells you how many sides and starters to add.
- Are the shellfish served in or out of the shell? Shell-on items look generous but contain less edible meat by weight.
- Which sauces come with it? You may want an extra sauce for the table or something on the side.
- Can the kitchen adjust it for allergies or preferences? Shellfish allergies affect the whole platter, because items often touch.
How do you make a mixed seafood grill the centerpiece of a shared meal?
A mixed seafood grill works as a shared centerpiece when you treat it as the main course and build lighter dishes around it. At a restaurant, that might mean a raw-bar item or a salad to start, the mixed grill for the table, and two or three sides passed family style. The same plan works at home.
- Start light: chilled shrimp, oysters, a crudo or a bright salad.
- Main course: the mixed grill on one large board or platter so everyone can choose.
- Sides: one starch, one vegetable and good bread for the juices.
- Finish: something cold and citrusy, such as sorbet or a lemon tart.
How do you choose seafood at the counter for a home mixed grill?
Choose seafood for a home mixed grill by contrast. Combine at least one firm fish, one sweet shellfish and one item with char or chew, and make sure each can hold together on grill grates. The table below compares common choices.
| Seafood | Flavor | Texture | Grill prep | Approximate grill time (medium-high heat) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Swordfish steak, 1 inch (2.5 cm) thick | Mild, meaty | Dense, steak-like | Oil and season; grill directly on grates | 4–5 minutes per side |
| Salmon fillet, skin on, 1 inch thick | Rich, buttery | Tender, flakes easily | Grill skin side down first; the skin protects the flesh | 6–8 minutes skin side, 2–3 minutes flesh side |
| Whole branzino or similar, about 1–1.5 lb (450–680 g) | Delicate, clean | Moist, soft flakes | Score, oil well, stuff with lemon and herbs | 6–8 minutes per side |
| Jumbo shrimp (16/20 count per lb), shell on or peeled | Sweet, briny | Snappy | Skewer to prevent falling through; devein | 2–3 minutes per side |
| Large dry sea scallops (U10–U12) | Very sweet | Soft, creamy center | Pat completely dry; remove side muscle; skewer or use a grill pan | About 2 minutes per side |
| Lobster tail, split lengthwise | Rich, sweet | Firm, springy | Brush with butter; start flesh side down | 5–7 minutes total, depending on size |
| Octopus, pre-cooked or braised | Mild, savory | Tender with charred edges | Braise until tender first; grill only to char | 3–4 minutes per side |
| Squid tubes and tentacles | Mild, slightly sweet | Tender if fast, rubbery if overcooked | Score tubes; very hot grill | 1–2 minutes per side |
Times are starting points. Thickness, grill heat and starting temperature all change the result, so check doneness instead of relying on the clock alone.
What to look for at the seafood counter
- Fish: a fresh, ocean-like smell, moist flesh that springs back, and clear eyes on whole fish.
- Scallops: ask for dry scallops, meaning untreated. Wet-packed scallops release liquid and struggle to brown.
- Shrimp: most shrimp sold as fresh was previously frozen. Buying frozen and thawing it yourself is often just as good.
- Thickness: fillets and steaks at least 1 inch thick stay juicier on a grill than thin pieces.
How much seafood do you need per person?
For a mixed seafood grill served as the main course, plan about 6–8 oz (170–225 g) of edible seafood per adult. Use the lower end when you are serving several starters and sides. Use the higher end when the grill is nearly the whole meal.
- Shell-on shrimp: buy a little more by weight than peeled, because shells are discarded.
- Whole fish: the edible yield is much lower than the purchased weight once you remove the head, bones and skin. A 1–1.5 lb whole fish usually serves one to two people as part of a mixed platter.
- Lobster tails: one small tail or half a large tail per person is usually enough alongside other seafood.
For a group of four, a balanced home platter might be one swordfish or salmon portion per two people, a pound of jumbo shrimp, eight large scallops and two lobster tails. Adjust the mix to your budget and appetites.
How do you grill mixed seafood at home step by step?
Grill mixed seafood by preparing everything first, then cooking items in order from longest to shortest time so they all finish together.
- Prep cold. Keep the seafood refrigerated until about 15–20 minutes before grilling. Pat every piece dry with paper towels.
- Season lightly. Use oil, salt and pepper, plus citrus zest or herbs. Add acidic marinades only for 15–30 minutes, because acid starts to break down delicate seafood.
- Skewer small items. Thread shrimp and scallops onto two parallel skewers so they don't spin. Soak wooden skewers in water for about 30 minutes first.
- Heat and clean the grill. Bring it to medium-high, roughly 400–450°F (205–230°C). Scrub the grates clean, then oil them just before cooking.
- Cook in stages. Start with whole fish and thick steaks. Add lobster tails and octopus next. Finish with shrimp, scallops and squid in the last few minutes.
- Don't move it too soon. Seafood releases from clean, oiled grates once a crust forms. If it sticks, wait another 30–60 seconds.
- Check doneness. Fish is done at 145°F (63°C) internal temperature, or when the flesh is opaque and separates easily with a fork. Shrimp and lobster turn opaque and pink-white. Scallops should be just opaque at the edges, with a slightly translucent center if you like them tender.
- Rest briefly and plate. Arrange everything on a warm platter. Finish with olive oil, flaky salt, lemon and herbs.
What sauces, sides and drinks go with a mixed seafood grill?
A mixed seafood grill pairs best with bright, acidic sauces and simple sides, because the char and natural sweetness of the seafood should stay in front.
Sauces
- Lemon-garlic butter: rich, and a classic match for lobster and scallops.
- Salsa verde or chimichurri: herby and sharp, good with swordfish, octopus and shrimp.
- Garlic aioli or romesco: creamy or nutty, and good for dipping grilled shellfish.
- Plain lemon wedges and good olive oil: the easiest option, and often enough.
Sides
- Grilled vegetables cooked on the same grill first, such as zucchini, peppers, asparagus or corn.
- Herbed potatoes, rice pilaf or a lemony orzo salad.
- A crisp green salad with a citrus vinaigrette.
- Crusty bread to soak up butter and juices.
Drinks
Crisp, high-acid white wines such as Albariño, Sauvignon Blanc, Chablis or Vermentino suit most seafood grills. Dry rosé handles a wide mix of fish and sauces. A light-bodied red like Pinot Noir can work with salmon or swordfish. For non-alcoholic options, sparkling water with citrus or an herb-infused lemonade matches the same bright profile.
What can you substitute to fit your budget or availability?
Swap any mixed-grill item for another with a similar texture and cooking time. That keeps the contrast intact while letting you buy what is fresh or affordable.
- Instead of swordfish: halibut, mahi-mahi or tuna steaks. Cook tuna briefly to keep the center rare.
- Instead of lobster tails: more jumbo shrimp, langoustines or split king crab legs warmed on the grill.
- Instead of scallops: large shrimp, or monkfish chunks on skewers.
- Instead of whole branzino: whole trout, snapper or porgy.
- Budget stretch: mussels or clams in a foil packet or cast-iron pan on the grill. They are inexpensive, look abundant and create a broth for bread.
How do you handle seafood safely for a grill night?
Safe seafood handling means keeping it cold, keeping raw and cooked items apart, and cooking it fully unless the item is meant to be served rare.
- Keep it cold: refrigerate seafood at 40°F (4°C) or below, and cook fresh fish and shellfish within one to two days of purchase.
- Thaw safely: thaw frozen seafood overnight in the refrigerator, or in a sealed bag under cold running water. Don't thaw it at room temperature.
- Separate raw and cooked: use one platter and set of tongs for raw seafood and clean ones for serving.
- Discard used marinade: don't use marinade that touched raw seafood as a sauce unless you boil it first.
- Live shellfish: discard clams or mussels that stay open when tapped before cooking, or that don't open after cooking.
- Time limits: don't leave cooked seafood out for more than 2 hours, or 1 hour when the temperature is above 90°F (32°C).
What can you make ahead for a mixed seafood grill?
Most of the work for a mixed seafood grill can be done in advance. The grilling itself should happen just before serving, because grilled seafood dries out when it is held or reheated.
- One day ahead: make salsa verde, chimichurri, aioli or romesco and refrigerate them. Braise octopus until tender and chill it in its liquid. Prepare grain salads.
- Morning of: peel and devein shrimp, trim scallops, split lobster tails and score whole fish. Store each item covered on its own tray in the refrigerator.
- One to two hours ahead: thread skewers, grill vegetables (they are good at room temperature) and set out the platters, lemons and herbs.
- At serving time: season the seafood, grill it in stages and bring it straight to the table.
Should you serve a mixed seafood grill on one platter or plated?
Serve a mixed seafood grill on one large platter when the meal is meant to be shared and relaxed. Plate individual portions when guests have allergies, when you need to control portions, or when the occasion is more formal. A platter creates the gathering-around-the-table feel of a seafood feast. Put sauces in small bowls around it and add an empty bowl for shells. Individual plates make it easier to keep shellfish away from a guest who can't eat it and to give everyone a fair share of the more expensive items, such as lobster.
Either way, the formula is the same as the one a seafood restaurant follows. Choose a few seafoods with contrasting textures, cook each one precisely, and let simple sauces and sides support them.
Related articles
Mixed Seafood Grill at Pappas
Discover how to plan a mixed seafood grill at Pappas, from seafood-counter choices to a table worth gathering around. Learn about flavors, textures, preparation, portions, pairings, and make-ahead options.
Pappadeaux Mixed Seafood Grill and Calorie Information for Seafood Boils & Shared Feasts
A practical guide to the Pappadeaux Mixed Seafood Grill, including its components, calorie range, flavor profile, and how to serve it alongside seafood boils and shared feasts.
Mixed Seafood Grill at Locanda Verde: The Centerpiece of a Shared Seafood Feast
Explore the Mixed Seafood Grill at Locanda Verde within the context of seafood boils and shared feasts. Learn about flavor, texture, preparation, and serving to plan the perfect table for your gathering.
Mixed Seafood Grill at Barbacoa
Learn how to build a mixed seafood grill barbacoa spread—from choosing seafood at the counter to grilling, seasoning, and serving a table worth gathering around.