Mackerel Fish Cakes
A plain guide to making mackerel fish cakes: choosing fresh or canned fish, binding the mix so it holds, pan-frying for a crisp crust, and serving a dipping sauce.
Contents
Mackerel fish cakes are patties of cooked, flaked mackerel mixed with a starch binder, shaped, and pan-fried until crisp outside and hot within. This page answers how to make fish cakes with mackerel, from choosing the fish to the pan and the sauce at the table. The method suits both canned and fresh mackerel, and the mix is forgiving enough to shape by hand.
Choosing fresh or canned mackerel
Canned or fresh mackerel both work for fish cakes, and each brings a different character to the mix. Canned mackerel is already cooked and soft, so it flakes with a fork and needs little handling. Fresh mackerel fillets must be cooked first, by poaching or baking, then cooled and flaked. Either way, drain the fish well, because extra liquid loosens the binder and makes the cakes fall apart.
Binding the mix so it holds
A binder is the ingredient that holds flaked mackerel together as a cake, and mashed potato is the familiar choice. Cooked potato, breadcrumbs, or a mixture of both absorbs moisture and gives the patty structure. Add a little beaten egg to bind further, and season with mustard, herbs, or lemon zest to cut the richness of the fish. Chill the shaped cakes before frying so they firm up and keep their shape in the pan.
Pan-frying for a crisp crust
Pan-frying gives mackerel fish cakes a browned, crisp surface while the inside heats through. Heat a shallow layer of oil over medium heat and lay the cakes in without crowding the pan. Fry each side until deep golden, turning once, and keep the heat moderate so the outside colors before the center overcooks. Drain the finished cakes briefly on paper, then serve them hot with a dipping sauce such as lemon mayonnaise or a sharp herb yogurt.
Questions About Mackerel Fish Cakes
How do you make fish cakes with mackerel?
Mackerel fish cakes are made by flaking cooked mackerel into mashed potato or breadcrumbs with egg and seasoning. You shape the mix into patties, chill them, and pan-fry each side until golden. Drain the fish well first so the binder holds and the cakes stay together in the pan.
Can you use canned mackerel for fish cakes?
Yes, canned mackerel works well for fish cakes because it is already cooked and flakes easily. Drain the can and mash the fish into the binder with a fork, keeping some texture. Canned mackerel saves the poaching step, so the cakes come together quickly.
What holds mackerel fish cakes together?
A binder holds mackerel fish cakes together, and mashed potato or breadcrumbs are the usual choices. Beaten egg adds extra stickiness, and chilling the shaped cakes firms them before frying. Too much liquid is the main reason a cake breaks up, so drain the fish and the potato.
What sauce goes with mackerel fish cakes?
A dipping sauce with acidity balances the rich flesh of mackerel fish cakes. Lemon mayonnaise, herb yogurt, or a vinegar-based sauce all work at the table. Serve the sauce alongside rather than poured over, so the fried crust stays crisp.