How to Crack Lobster: Recipe and Method

Learn how to crack a cooked lobster cleanly, open the claws and tail, pull out every piece of meat, and use it in a simple recipe.

8 min read15 viewsHow to Crack Lobster: Recipe and Method
— · 0 votes
Contents
  1. Start with a fully cooked lobster
  2. How to open the claws and knuckles
  3. How to crack the tail shell
  4. Open the body for small pieces of meat
  5. Tools that make cracking easier
  6. A simple recipe for cracked lobster meat
  7. Keep shell fragments out of the meat
  8. Handle lobster with care in the kitchen
  9. Questions About Cracking Lobster
  10. Can I crack a lobster before cooking it?
  11. What tool do I use to crack lobster?
  12. How do I get the meat out of the claws without tearing it?
  13. Is the green stuff inside a lobster safe to eat?
  14. How should I store cracked lobster meat?

Cracking lobster means opening the shell in a set order so the meat comes out in whole pieces. Work from the claws to the tail, using a lobster cracker and a pick, and keep the shell steady on a board. The meat you free is ready for a simple butter recipe or any dish that calls for cooked lobster.

  • Cook or buy the lobster already steamed, then let it cool enough to handle before cracking.
  • Open the claws first, then the knuckles, then the tail, so each piece of meat stays whole.
  • Use a lobster cracker on the shell and a pick for the thin parts near the joints.
  • Crack each section with short squeezes, because crushing the shell tears the meat.
  • Keep the shell pieces and any juices to flavor butter for the recipe.

Start with a fully cooked lobster

A lobster must be cooked before you crack it, because the shell is opened to reach ready-to-eat meat. Steamed lobster is the simplest starting point, and it can be chilled in the fridge before cracking. Cooling firms the meat, which helps it slide out of the shell in one piece.

Set the lobster on a cutting board with a lip or a rimmed tray, since juices will run out. Have a lobster cracker, a small fork or pick, and a bowl for the meat within reach. A clean kitchen towel under the board keeps the shell from sliding while you press down.

Twist off the claws and knuckles before you open the body, and set them beside the board. Separate the tail from the body with a firm twist at the joint. Keep the pieces in the order you will crack them so nothing gets lost.

How to open the claws and knuckles

The claws hold the largest piece of meat, so open them first while your hands are fresh. Hold a claw over the bowl and squeeze the lobster cracker across the widest part of the shell. A short, firm squeeze cracks the shell without crushing what is inside.

Peel the cracked shell away in pieces and lift the claw meat out with your fingers. Work along the claw to the knuckle joint, cracking again where the shell is thick. Run a pick through the narrow end to push out any meat that stays behind.

The knuckles are smaller and need a lighter hand on the cracker. Crack each knuckle at its joint and push the meat out with the pick from the open end. Small pieces from the knuckles are good for the recipe, so keep them with the claw meat.

  • Hold the claw over a bowl to catch juices.
  • Squeeze the cracker across the widest part of the shell.
  • Peel the shell away in small pieces.
  • Lift the meat out with your fingers.
  • Push remaining meat from the joints with a pick.

How to crack the tail shell

The tail is the longest section and the shell is harder along its back. Press the cracker along the center line of the tail, working from the wide end toward the fan. Crack in two or three places rather than one hard squeeze.

Pull the cracked shell apart with both hands and ease the tail meat out in one piece. If the shell resists, crack it again at the next segment instead of forcing it. A pick helps free the meat where it meets the fan at the end.

Some cooks split the tail with kitchen shears along the back before cracking. Shears give a clean line and leave the meat whole, which suits a recipe that slices the lobster. Whichever method you use, keep the tail meat on the board and check it for shell fragments.

Open the body for small pieces of meat

The body holds small amounts of meat in the cavities between the shell segments. Break the body apart over the bowl and pick out the meat with a small fork. This meat suits the recipe as well, though it comes out in shreds rather than whole pieces.

The tomalley is the green material inside the body of a cooked lobster, and some cooks keep it for sauce. The coral, or roe, appears in some lobsters and can be stirred into butter. Decide before you start whether you want either one, then set them aside.

Discard the sac near the head and the dark vein along the tail before you use the meat. Rinse the meat only if shell bits cling to it, since water washes away flavor. Pat the pieces dry before the recipe so butter coats them rather than sliding off.

Tools that make cracking easier

A lobster cracker is a hinged tool with ridged jaws that grip the shell without crushing it. Kitchen shears cut along a tail or a claw and are useful when the shell is thin. A pick or a small fork reaches meat in the knuckles and the joints.

A heavy cutting board gives a steady surface, and a bowl beside it catches the meat and juices. A towel under the board stops it from sliding when you press the cracker down. Keep a second bowl for empty shell pieces to clear the work area.

A nutcracker can stand in for a lobster cracker on small claws, though its jaws are narrow. A meat mallet is a poor choice because a blow shatters the shell into the meat. Choose a tool that squeezes rather than strikes, and wash it after contact with raw shellfish.

A simple recipe for cracked lobster meat

This recipe uses the meat from one cooked lobster and takes little time at the stove. Melt butter in a skillet over medium heat and add a squeeze of lemon. Add the lobster meat and warm it gently, turning the pieces once, until they are hot through.

Do not boil the meat, because cooked lobster turns rubbery when it is overheated. Take the skillet off the heat as soon as the pieces are warm and coat them in the butter. Season with salt and a little black pepper, then spoon the meat over toast, pasta or rice.

The shells and juices you saved can go into the butter for more flavor. Simmer the shells in melted butter for a few minutes, then strain them out before the meat goes in. Serve the dish right away, with lemon on the side and the shell pieces discarded.

  • Melt butter in a skillet over medium heat.
  • Add lemon juice to the butter.
  • Warm the lobster meat gently, turning once.
  • Season with salt and black pepper.
  • Spoon over toast, pasta or rice.

Keep shell fragments out of the meat

Shell fragments are the main hazard when you crack lobster, and they hide in the folds of the meat. Run your fingers over each piece before it goes into the bowl. Hold the meat up to the light to spot small chips against the white flesh.

Crack the shell over a separate area from the bowl of meat so pieces fall away from what you keep. Wipe the board between sections if shell dust builds up. A quick rinse of the board at the end keeps fragments out of the next job.

Handle lobster with care in the kitchen

The shell edges and the spiny legs of a lobster can cut a hand, so grip the pieces by the smooth parts. Keep your fingers clear of the cracker jaws when you squeeze. A cut from a shell should be washed and covered before you continue.

Cooked lobster that has been out of the fridge should not sit long before it is eaten or chilled. Keep the meat cold until the recipe starts, and reheat it only until it is warm. Live lobster needs handling that suits your local rules, and a fishmonger can advise on that.

Questions About Cracking Lobster

Can I crack a lobster before cooking it?

No, crack a lobster after it is cooked, because the shell is opened to reach ready-to-eat meat. Raw lobster meat is harder to free and needs a separate method of preparation. Steam or boil the lobster first, then let it cool before you crack it.

What tool do I use to crack lobster?

A lobster cracker is the right tool, because its ridged jaws squeeze the shell without crushing the meat. A pick or small fork reaches meat in the knuckles and joints. Kitchen shears work well for splitting a tail shell along the back.

How do I get the meat out of the claws without tearing it?

Crack the claw at the widest part with a short, firm squeeze, then peel the shell away in small pieces. Lift the meat out with your fingers rather than pulling hard. A pick pushed from the narrow end frees meat that stays in the joint.

Is the green stuff inside a lobster safe to eat?

The green tomalley is edible and some cooks use it to flavor sauce or butter. The coral, or roe, is also edible and appears in some lobsters. Remove the sac near the head and the dark vein along the tail before eating the meat.

How should I store cracked lobster meat?

Keep cracked lobster meat covered and cold until the recipe begins, because cooked shellfish spoils quickly outside the fridge. Use a clean container and keep the meat away from raw foods. Reheat it gently and only until it is warm.

Read next

Latest articles