Fish Patties for McDonald's-Style Sandwiches
How to make fish patties like McDonald's at home: which white fish to buy, shaping square patties, breading, cooking, buns, tartar sauce, cheese, portions and make-ahead tips.
Contents
- What makes fish patties like McDonald's different from other fish cakes?
- Which fish works best for fish patties for sandwiches?
- How to choose fish at the seafood counter
- Whole fillet squares or formed patties: which should you make?
- How to make fish patties for sandwiches step by step
- Prepare and shape the fish
- Bread the patties
- Cook the patties
- How to build a McDonald's-style fish sandwich
- Sandwich buns
- Tartar sauce
- Cheese
- Optional add-ons
- How much fish do you need per sandwich?
- Menu ideas and pairings for a fish sandwich meal
- Substitutions for different diets and budgets
- Can you make fish patties ahead and freeze them?
- Safe handling tips for fish patties
A good fish patty for a McDonald's-style sandwich is a thin, square piece of mild, flaky white fish such as pollock, cod or haddock. It has a fine, crisp breadcrumb coating and is cooked until just opaque. It goes on a soft steamed bun with tartar sauce and a half slice of melty cheese. The Filet-O-Fish is the familiar model. At home you can match its gentle flavor and tidy shape with fish from any seafood counter or freezer aisle. You need simple pantry breading and about 30 to 45 minutes of hands-on time.
This guide covers choosing the fish, shaping and breading the patties, and cooking them. It also covers building the sandwich and planning portions, sides and make-ahead steps for a casual meal.
What makes fish patties like McDonald's different from other fish cakes?
Fish patties like McDonald's differ from classic fish cakes in three ways. They are made from almost pure white fish with no potato or heavy filler. They have a uniform square patty shape. They have a thin, even crumb coat rather than a thick batter. Classic fish cakes are softer and more savory because they often contain mashed potato, herbs and onion. Battered fish, as in fish and chips, is puffier and greasier. A sandwich patty needs to be flat, mild and evenly crisp so it stacks neatly between sandwich buns and lets the tartar sauce carry the flavor.
- Flavor: clean and mild, lightly salted, with no strong fishiness.
- Texture: a crisp, fine-crumb shell over moist, flaky or tender-compact fish.
- Shape: square or rectangular and roughly 1 to 2 cm (about ½ to ¾ inch) thick, so it cooks quickly and evenly.
Which fish works best for fish patties for sandwiches?
The best fish for sandwich patties is a lean, mild, white-fleshed fish that holds together when cooked. The Filet-O-Fish is made with Alaska pollock. Cod, haddock, hake and whiting give very similar results. Choose by price, availability and how firm you want the bite to be.
| Fish | Flavor | Texture when cooked | Notes for sandwich patties |
|---|---|---|---|
| Alaska pollock | Very mild | Soft, fine flakes | Closest to the fast-food style; often sold frozen and budget-friendly |
| Cod | Mild, slightly sweet | Large, tender flakes | Widely available; thick loins cut into neat squares |
| Haddock | Mild, a little sweeter than cod | Fine, delicate flakes | Thinner fillets; good for formed patties |
| Hake or whiting | Mild | Soft | Economical; handle gently because the flesh is delicate |
| Tilapia | Mild, slightly earthy | Firmer, less flaky | Inexpensive substitute; fillets are thin, so stack or form them |
Oily fish such as salmon or mackerel make tasty patties, but the result will not taste like a McDonald's-style fish sandwich. Save them for a different menu.
How to choose fish at the seafood counter
For sandwich patties, buy skinless, boneless white fish fillets that look moist and smell fresh and briny, not sour. Frozen fillets are a perfectly good choice and are often easier to cut into even squares.
- Ask for center cuts or loins if you plan to cut whole pieces. They are thicker and more even than tail ends.
- Tail pieces and trimmings are often cheaper and work well for formed patties, because the fish gets chopped anyway.
- Check for pin bones by running a finger along the fillet. Pull out any bones with tweezers or pliers.
- Frozen blocks or individually frozen fillets should be solidly frozen, with little frost or ice crystals inside the packaging.
Whole fillet squares or formed patties: which should you make?
Whole fillet squares are quicker and have big, natural flakes. Formed patties are made from chopped fish pressed into a mold. They are more uniform and closer to the compact texture of commercial breaded white fish. Both work well on a sandwich.
| Method | Texture | Effort | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whole fillet squares | Flaky, chunky, very fresh-tasting | Low: trim, cut and bread | Weeknight dinners and thick cod or pollock loins |
| Formed (chopped) patties | Even, tender, holds a sharp square edge | Medium: chop, shape and chill or freeze before breading | The closest copycat result, thin or irregular fillets, and batch cooking |
How to make fish patties for sandwiches step by step
Homemade fish patties for sandwiches take four stages: prepare the fish, shape it, bread it, then cook it. The steps below work for both whole fillet and formed patties.
Prepare and shape the fish
- Dry the fish. Thaw frozen fish in the refrigerator, then pat it very dry with paper towels. Excess moisture makes the coating slide off.
- For whole fillet squares: cut the fish into squares about 9 to 10 cm (3½ to 4 inches) across. If the fillets are thick, slice them horizontally to an even thickness of about 1.5 cm (⅝ inch).
- For formed patties: cut the fish into chunks and pulse briefly in a food processor until coarsely chopped, not pasty. Season lightly with salt and white or black pepper. Press the mixture firmly into a square mold, or into a parchment-lined square pan that you cut into portions later.
- Chill or freeze to firm. Formed patties hold their shape much better if they are frozen until firm, about 1 hour, before breading. Whole squares only need to stay cold.
Bread the patties
- Set up three shallow dishes: seasoned flour, beaten egg (thinned with a spoonful of water or milk), and fine dry breadcrumbs.
- Coat in order: flour, then egg, then crumbs. Press the crumbs on so they stick evenly to the edges.
- Choose your crumb. Fine, plain breadcrumbs give the smooth, even look of a fast-food patty. Panko gives a crunchier, more jagged crust that tastes great but looks less like the original.
- Rest the breaded patties on a rack in the refrigerator for 10 to 15 minutes, or freeze them for later. The coating sets and stays on better during cooking.
Cook the patties
Cook fish patties until the coating is golden and the fish reaches an internal temperature of 63°C (145°F), or flakes easily and looks opaque in the center. Formed patties cooked from frozen will take a few minutes longer than chilled ones.
| Method | How to do it | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Deep or shallow frying | Heat neutral oil to about 175–180°C (350–360°F). Fry in small batches, turning once, until golden. Drain on a rack. | Most authentic: even, crisp, golden crust |
| Air frying | Spray or brush both sides lightly with oil. Cook in a single layer at about 200°C (400°F), flipping halfway. | Crisp with little oil; slightly drier crust |
| Oven baking | Bake on an oiled rack set over a sheet pan at about 220°C (425°F), turning once. | Easiest for a crowd; least crisp, so toasting the crumbs in oil first helps |
Whichever method you choose, salt the hot patties lightly as soon as they come out. This brings out the mild fish flavor.
How to build a McDonald's-style fish sandwich
A McDonald's-style fish sandwich is assembled in this order: soft bun bottom, hot fish patty, a half slice of cheese, tartar sauce, and the bun top. The heat from the patty softens the cheese. The steamed bun keeps everything tender rather than crusty.
Sandwich buns
Plain, soft white sandwich buns without seeds are the classic choice. Potato rolls or soft brioche-style buns also work. To get the soft, pillowy texture, steam the buns for 30 to 60 seconds in a steamer basket over simmering water. Alternatively, wrap them in a damp towel and warm them briefly in the microwave. Toasting gives more structure if the sandwiches will sit for a while.
Tartar sauce
Tartar sauce for a fish sandwich is mayonnaise mixed with finely chopped pickles or relish, a little minced onion, and lemon juice. Capers and fresh dill are optional additions. Make it at least 30 minutes ahead so the flavors blend. Keep it refrigerated until serving. Spread it generously but not to the edges, so it does not squeeze out.
Cheese
A half slice of processed American cheese is the traditional topping. It melts smoothly and adds a salty, creamy note without overpowering the fish. Mild cheddar or Monterey Jack slices are good alternatives. Leave the cheese off entirely for a lighter, more fish-forward sandwich.
Optional add-ons
- Shredded iceberg lettuce for crunch
- Thin pickle slices or a few capers for sharpness
- A squeeze of lemon on the hot patty
- Hot sauce or a spicy mayonnaise for adults who want more heat
How much fish do you need per sandwich?
Plan on about 85–115 g (3–4 oz) of raw, boneless fish per sandwich patty. About 450 g (1 lb) of fillets makes roughly four standard patties. For hungry eaters or a double-patty sandwich, allow two patties per person. For children, a single smaller patty, cut from a 6–7 cm (2½-inch) square, is usually enough.
| Number of sandwiches | Raw boneless fish (approx.) | Buns |
|---|---|---|
| 4 | 350–450 g (¾–1 lb) | 4 |
| 8 | 700–900 g (1½–2 lb) | 8 |
| 12 | 1–1.4 kg (2¼–3 lb) | 12 |
Buy a little extra if you are cutting whole fillets, because trimming into neat squares leaves offcuts. Those scraps can be pressed into a formed patty or breaded as fish nuggets.
Menu ideas and pairings for a fish sandwich meal
Fish sandwiches pair best with crisp, tangy or fresh sides that balance the fried coating. The fast-food combo of fries and a cold drink is the simplest route. A few homemade sides turn it into a relaxed meal worth gathering around.
- Classic: French fries or oven wedges, a creamy or vinegar coleslaw, and dill pickles.
- Lighter: a crunchy green salad with lemon dressing, cucumber salad, or corn on the cob.
- Kid-friendly: mini patties on slider buns, carrot sticks and apple slices.
- Friday fish fry or casual party: set up a sandwich bar with steamed buns, a platter of hot patties, tartar sauce, cheese, lettuce, pickles and a couple of sauces. Guests can then build their own.
- Drinks: lemonade, iced tea, a crisp lager, or a light dry white wine all suit mild breaded fish.
Substitutions for different diets and budgets
Fish patties for sandwiches adapt easily to common dietary needs by swapping the coating and condiments.
- Gluten-free: use rice flour or a gluten-free flour blend, and gluten-free breadcrumbs or crushed cornflakes. Serve on gluten-free buns.
- Egg-free: replace the egg wash with a thin batter of flour and water, or with plain mayonnaise thinned slightly. Use an egg-free mayo for the tartar sauce.
- Dairy-free: skip the cheese or use a plant-based slice, and check that the buns are dairy-free.
- Budget: frozen pollock, hake or whiting fillets are usually the most economical. Formed patties make good use of cheaper tail pieces and trimmings.
- Short on time: good-quality frozen breaded fish fillets can stand in for homemade patties. Homemade tartar sauce and steamed buns still make the sandwich taste special.
Can you make fish patties ahead and freeze them?
Yes. Breaded, uncooked fish patties freeze well and can be cooked directly from frozen, which makes them ideal for make-ahead meals. Freezing raw breaded patties gives a crisper result than freezing cooked ones.
- Shape and bread the patties as described above.
- Freeze them in a single layer on a parchment-lined tray until solid.
- Transfer them to a freezer bag or airtight container, with parchment between layers. Press out the air, then label and date the bag.
- Cook from frozen by frying, air-frying or baking, adding a few minutes. Check that the center reaches 63°C (145°F).
For best quality, use frozen homemade patties within about 2 to 3 months. Tartar sauce can be made 1 to 2 days ahead and kept covered in the refrigerator. Cooked patties are best eaten fresh. Leftovers can be refrigerated and reheated in an oven or air fryer to restore some crispness, but the microwave makes the coating soggy.
Safe handling tips for fish patties
Safe handling of fish for sandwich patties comes down to keeping it cold, keeping raw fish separate, and cooking it to 63°C (145°F).
- Keep fresh fish cold and use it within 1 to 2 days of purchase, or freeze it.
- Thaw frozen fish in the refrigerator, or in a sealed bag under cold running water. Never thaw it at room temperature.
- Use separate boards and utensils for raw fish and for ready-to-eat foods like buns, lettuce and cheese. Wash your hands after handling raw fish.
- Discard leftover flour, egg and crumbs that have touched raw fish. Do not reuse them.
- Refrigerate leftovers promptly, within 2 hours of cooking. Keep tartar sauce chilled rather than leaving it out on a buffet for long periods.
With mild white fish, a neat square patty shape, a crisp crumb coat, a soft bun, tartar sauce and a little cheese, homemade fish patties like McDonald's are an affordable, crowd-pleasing meal. They suit a quick weeknight dinner as well as a relaxed table for family and friends.