Environmental Impact of Trawl Fishing

Trawl fishing drags nets across the seabed or through open water. This page explains seabed damage, bycatch, habitat disturbance and carbon release from disturbed sediment.

3 min read7 viewsEnvironmental Impact of Trawl Fishing
— · 0 votes
Contents
  1. How bottom trawling damages the seabed
  2. Bycatch and the food web
  3. Carbon release from seabed sediment
  4. Questions about trawl fishing effects
  5. What are the main environmental impacts of trawl fishing?
  6. Is bottom trawling worse for the seabed than other fishing methods?
  7. How does trawl fishing cause overfishing?
  8. Does trawling release carbon from the seabed?

The environmental impact of trawl fishing comes from dragging a net through the water or along the seabed, which removes fish, disturbs sediment and catches untargeted animals. Bottom trawling is the form that contacts the seabed directly. Trawl nets also produce bycatch, the catch of animals the crew did not mean to take. Together these effects link trawl fishing to seabed damage and overfishing.

How bottom trawling damages the seabed

Bottom trawling pulls weighted trawl nets and doors across the seabed. This gear scours seabed damage into soft and rocky ground and flattens the structure that benthic ecosystems build over time. Habitat disturbance continues after the pass, because disturbed sediment resettles and slow-growing seabed animals recover slowly. The severity depends on the seabed type, the gear design and how often the same ground is fished.

Bycatch and the food web

Bycatch is the part of the catch that the crew did not target, and it can include fish, shellfish, seabirds and marine mammals. Trawl nets that fish for one species therefore remove other animals from the food web. Overfishing can follow when bycatch removes young fish before they can reproduce. Gear design and the area fished influence how much bycatch a tow produces.

Carbon release from seabed sediment

Carbon release from seabed sediment is a debated effect of bottom trawling. Trawled sediment can release stored carbon back into the water, and the amount depends on sediment type, trawl penetration and the water conditions. The size of this effect is not settled, so it should not be treated as a fixed figure. Reducing how deeply gear penetrates the seabed limits both carbon disturbance and physical seabed damage.

Questions about trawl fishing effects

What are the main environmental impacts of trawl fishing?

The main trawl fishing effects are removal of target and non-target animals, seabed damage from bottom gear, habitat disturbance and possible carbon release from sediment. Bycatch affects animals the crew did not intend to catch, including seabirds and marine mammals. Bottom trawling adds direct contact with the seabed. Open-water trawling avoids the seabed but still removes fish and produces bycatch.

Is bottom trawling worse for the seabed than other fishing methods?

Bottom trawling causes more seabed damage than methods that never touch the seabed. Tow duration, gear weight and sediment type all change the severity of the damage. Slow-growing benthic ecosystems recover slowly after a pass. Open-water gear does not contact the seabed, so it avoids this seabed damage.

How does trawl fishing cause overfishing?

Trawl fishing can cause overfishing when it removes fish faster than the stock can replace them. Bycatch adds to the removal of non-target fish, including juveniles that would become the next breeding stock. Avoiding vulnerable areas and bycatch limits reduce the pressure. The overall outcome depends on the strength of management for each stock.

Does trawling release carbon from the seabed?

Trawling can release carbon from seabed sediment when gear disturbs stored carbon, but the scale of that release is still debated. The released carbon is not fixed and it depends on sediment type, trawl penetration and water conditions. Claims of a fixed carbon figure for trawl fishing should be treated with caution. Less intrusive gear reduces both carbon disturbance and seabed damage.

Read next

Latest articles