Butterfly Squid Recipe

Learn how to butterfly squid, marinate it, and cook it fast for a tender garlic butter or grilled Filipino squid dish with a simple recipe.

8 min read1 views
— · 0 votes
Contents
  1. What butterflying squid means
  2. Cleaning and prepping the squid
  3. Scoring for tenderness and shape
  4. A simple marinade for squid
  5. Pan-searing butterfly squid
  6. Grilling butterflied squid
  7. Cooking time and doneness
  8. Serving and storing the dish
  9. Butterfly Squid Questions
  10. What is a butterfly squid recipe?
  11. Is there a Panlasang Pinoy butterfly squid recipe?
  12. How long should I marinate squid?
  13. How do I stop squid from turning rubbery?
  14. Can I use the tentacles in the same dish?
  15. What can I serve with garlic butter squid?

A butterfly squid recipe starts with opening a cleaned squid body flat so it cooks evenly and curls less. You score the flesh lightly, marinate it briefly, and cook it hot and fast. The result is tender squid that takes on garlic butter, grilled smoke, or a Filipino-style marinade.

  • Butterflying means cutting the squid tube open along one side and laying it flat.
  • Light scoring keeps the flesh tender and helps it stay flat on the heat.
  • Squid turns rubbery when overcooked, so keep the cooking time short and the heat high.
  • A short marinade adds flavor without breaking down the flesh.
  • Grilled and pan-seared butterfly squid both work with garlic butter or a soy-calamansi marinade.

What butterflying squid means

Butterflying squid means splitting the body tube lengthwise and opening it into a flat sheet. The cleaned squid is laid out so the inside faces up and the flesh forms a single even piece. This flat shape cooks at one thickness instead of curling into a tube.

A flat piece of squid browns more evenly in a hot pan or on a grill grate. The scored side makes contact with the heat, so the surface sears instead of steaming. Butterflied squid also plates neatly and takes a marinade across more surface area.

You can butterfly small and medium squid, and larger tubes give wider sheets for stuffing or rolling. The technique is the same whatever size you buy at the seafood counter. Ask the fishmonger to clean the squid if you prefer to start from ready tubes.

Cleaning and prepping the squid

Cleaning squid means removing the head, the quill, and the innards before you butterfly the body. Pull the head away gently with the tentacles attached, then lift out the clear plastic-like quill. Rinse the inside of the tube under cool water and rub away any loose membrane.

Hold the tube with the opening facing you and cut along one side from top to bottom with a sharp knife. Open the body flat and press it skin-side down on the board. Keep the tentacles whole; they cook quickly and make a good addition to the same dish.

Pat the flat squid dry with paper towels before scoring or marinating. Dry flesh sears better and holds a marinade instead of releasing water. A clean board and a sharp knife make this prep safer and faster.

Scoring for tenderness and shape

Scoring squid means cutting shallow lines into the inner flesh in a diamond pattern without slicing through. Light diagonal cuts stop the sheet from buckling and help it stay flat. The cuts also open small pockets that catch marinade and garlic butter.

Use a sharp knife and cut only a few millimeters deep. Deep cuts tear the sheet and cause it to break apart on the heat. Keep the lines close together and even so the squid cooks at the same rate across the sheet.

Some cooks skip scoring when the squid is small and thin. A thin sheet needs less help to stay flat and can toughen if cut too deep. Score larger or thicker tubes, and leave small ones whole if you prefer.

A simple marinade for squid

A marinade for squid should add flavor without soaking the flesh for too long. Acid and salt soften the surface, so a short rest is enough. Keep the mix light so the squid still tastes of the sea.

For a garlic butter squid, combine melted butter, minced garlic, lemon juice, salt, and black pepper. For a Filipino squid dish, use soy sauce, calamansi or lemon juice, garlic, and a little sugar. Toss the butterflied squid in the mix and let it sit while the pan or grill heats.

Oil the squid lightly before it hits the heat to stop it sticking. Shake off excess marinade so the surface sears instead of stewing. Save a little fresh marinade to spoon over after cooking, and discard any that touched raw squid.

  • Garlic butter: melted butter, minced garlic, lemon juice, salt, pepper
  • Filipino style: soy sauce, calamansi or lemon juice, garlic, small amount of sugar
  • Herb and oil: olive oil, chopped parsley, garlic, pinch of salt
  • Spicy: chili flakes, garlic, oil, squeeze of lime

Pan-searing butterfly squid

Pan-searing butterfly squid needs a heavy pan heated until it is very hot before the squid goes in. A hot surface sears the flesh fast and keeps it tender. Add a little oil and lay the squid scored-side down, pressing it flat for a moment.

Cook the sheet for a short time on each side until it turns opaque and lightly browned. Squid toughens when it stays on the heat too long, so watch the color rather than the clock. Remove it to a warm plate as soon as the flesh is firm and white.

Finish the pan with butter, garlic, and a squeeze of lemon, then spoon the sauce over the squid. A quick toss in the hot garlic butter adds flavor without more cooking. Serve right away so the squid does not sit and release water.

Grilling butterflied squid

Grilled squid works well with the butterfly cut because the flat sheet lies across the grate. Heat the grill until it is hot and oil both the grate and the squid. Place the sheet scored-side down and let it take color before turning.

Turn the squid once and brush it with marinade or garlic butter during the last part of cooking. Brushing early can cause flare-ups and burn the surface. Pull the squid off when it is opaque and lightly charred at the edges.

Grilled squid suits a Filipino squid dish served with rice and a dipping sauce of vinegar, garlic, and chili. Let the grilled sheet rest for a moment, then slice it into strips across the score lines. Tentacles can go on the grill too and cook even faster.

Cooking time and doneness

Cooking time for squid depends on the thickness of the sheet and the heat of your pan or grill. Thin squid cooks in a very short time, while a thick tube needs a little longer. Judge doneness by look and feel, not by a fixed number of minutes.

Raw squid is translucent and soft, and cooked squid turns opaque white and firm. The moment it is opaque and springs back lightly, it is ready. Further cooking makes the flesh rubbery and tight.

If you cook squid in a sauce or stew, a longer gentle simmer gives a different texture than a fast sear. Fast, high heat suits butterfly squid best. Keep the pieces even in thickness so they finish together.

Serving and storing the dish

Butterfly squid goes well with steamed rice, a crisp salad, or grilled vegetables. Spoon the pan juices or garlic butter over the top just before serving. A squeeze of citrus at the table lifts the richness of the butter.

Leftover squid is best eaten soon because it toughens when reheated. Store cooked squid covered in the refrigerator and use it cold in a salad rather than reheating it hard. Discard any marinade that touched raw squid.

Buy squid that smells fresh and has firm, shiny flesh, then cook it the same day if you can. Keep raw squid cold and separate from ready-to-eat food. Clean your board and knife well after handling raw seafood.

Butterfly Squid Questions

What is a butterfly squid recipe?

A butterfly squid recipe is a method where the squid body is cut open and flattened before cooking. The flat sheet is scored, marinated, and cooked fast on a pan or grill. The cut gives even cooking and a neat shape for serving.

Is there a Panlasang Pinoy butterfly squid recipe?

Panlasang Pinoy is a Filipino cooking resource, and a Filipino squid dish in that style uses soy sauce, calamansi, and garlic. You can apply that marinade to butterflied squid and grill or pan-sear it. Serve it with rice and a vinegar dip for a Filipino table.

How long should I marinate squid?

Squid needs only a short rest in the marinade, just enough time to absorb flavor. A long soak in acid can make the flesh soft and mushy. Toss it in the marinade while the pan or grill heats, then cook it.

How do I stop squid from turning rubbery?

Squid turns rubbery when it is cooked too long or at too low a heat. Use a hot pan or grill and pull the squid off as soon as it turns opaque and firm. Avoid reheating cooked squid hard.

Can I use the tentacles in the same dish?

Yes, the tentacles can be cooked with the butterflied body. They are thinner and cook faster, so add them to the pan or grill slightly later. Keep them whole and serve them alongside the sliced sheet.

What can I serve with garlic butter squid?

Garlic butter squid pairs with steamed rice, crusty bread, or a simple green salad. Grilled vegetables and a squeeze of lemon balance the rich butter. A vinegar and chili dip adds a sharp contrast.

Latest articles