Best Fish for Grilling
Learn which fish suits a hot grill, how firm flesh and whole fish behave over fire, and how to choose white fish, oily fish and seafood for grilling.
Contents
- Why firm flesh handles the grill
- Whole fish and seafood on the grill
- Choosing fish where you live
- Questions about grilling fish
- What is the best white fish to cook on the grill?
- Which fish is easy to grill on a barbecue or gas grill?
- Can I grill a whole fish?
- What seafood besides fish is good for grilling?
The best fish for grilling are firm-fleshed fish that hold together over direct heat, such as salmon, tuna, swordfish, mahi mahi and thick white fillets like cod or halibut. Flesh texture matters more than the species name, because a soft fillet falls apart on the grill grates while a dense one turns cleanly. Whole fish and sturdy seafood such as shrimp and squid also grill well when handled with care. Local catches vary by region, so the same firm texture test works whether you shop in Asia, Africa, the Gulf, Australia or anywhere else.
Why firm flesh handles the grill
Firm-fleshed fish keeps its shape because the muscle fibers bind tightly and hold moisture as they cook. A soft fillet collapses when lifted, so it tears through the grill grates and loses its crust. Choose fillets with a compact grain, a moist but not watery surface and an even thickness. Oily fish such as salmon and tuna suit high heat, while lean white fish needs a gentler fire and a little oil.
Whole fish and seafood on the grill
A whole fish grills well when it is gutted, scaled and scored so heat reaches the thickest part. Ask the fishmonger to clean it, then oil the skin and the grill grates before cooking. Shrimp, squid, octopus and thick shellfish steaks from tuna or swordfish are grill-safe seafood that cooks quickly over fire. Small shellfish can drop through the grates, so use a fine grill basket for those pieces.
Choosing fish where you live
Regional fish varieties differ in name but share the same texture test, so look for a firm body and tight flakes at the counter. Kerala, Nigeria, Pakistan, the Philippines, India and the Gulf all have local firm fish that suit a barbecue, such as groupers, snappers, kingfish and mackerel-like species. Ask the seller which local catch holds together on a grill rather than naming an imported species. On a gas grill, keep the lid down and the heat moderate so the outside does not burn before the center cooks.
Questions about grilling fish
What is the best white fish to cook on the grill?
Thick white fillets such as cod, halibut, haddock and similar firm white fish grill well because they stay intact over heat. Grilling white fish rewards an oiled surface and a gentle fire, since lean flesh dries quickly. Choose a fillet at least an inch thick so the center cooks before the outside toughens. A grill basket helps when the fillet is thin or delicate.
Which fish is easy to grill on a barbecue or gas grill?
Salmon, swordfish, tuna and mahi mahi are easy to grill on a barbecue or gas grill because their dense flesh releases cleanly from the grates. Whole fish and thick white fillets also work when the grill is clean, oiled and set to moderate heat. Turn the fish only once and use a wide spatula or tongs to support the fillet. A grill basket or a cedar plank salmon setup helps when you want extra protection.
Can I grill a whole fish?
Yes, whole fish grills well when it is cleaned, scaled and scored on both sides so heat penetrates evenly. Oil the skin and the grill grates, then cook over moderate heat and turn once with a sturdy spatula. A whole fish suits the grill because the bones and skin hold the flesh together as it cooks. Larger whole fish need a gentler fire so the center cooks through without scorching the skin.
What seafood besides fish is good for grilling?
Shrimp, squid, octopus, scallops and lobster tails all grill well when handled with care and moderate heat. Shrimp and squid cook fast, so watch them closely and turn once. Scallops and lobster tails need a steady fire and a light oil coating to avoid sticking. Use a grill basket for small pieces that might fall through the grates.