# Seared Scallops Technique and Recipe

Learn pan seared scallops technique and a simple recipe: dry the scallops, heat the skillet hard, sear a caramelized crust and finish with lemon butter sauce.

Seared scallops come down to two things: dry scallops and a very hot pan. You pat the scallops dry, season them, and lay them in a skillet with a little oil so the surface forms a caramelized crust in a couple of minutes. A butter baste at the end adds richness, and a lemon butter sauce finishes the plate. 

- Buy dry-packed scallops so they sear instead of steaming.
- Pat the scallops dry and season them just before they go in the pan.
- Heat the skillet until the oil shimmers before adding the scallops.
- Sear one side undisturbed for the crust, then turn and baste with butter.
- Pull the scallops off the heat as soon as the center turns opaque.
 

## Choosing scallops that sear well 

Dry scallops are the kind you want for pan searing, because they are not soaked in a phosphate solution before packing. Wet scallops hold water that leaks into the pan and steams the surface instead of browning it. 

Sea scallops are the large ones that suit a hot skillet, while smaller bay scallops cook so fast that they are easier to use in pasta or a quick saute. Ask at the seafood counter whether the scallops are dry-packed before you buy them. 

Fresh dry scallops smell sweet and clean, and their flesh looks creamy white. A faint gray or tan tone is fine, but a strong fishy smell or a milky liquid in the tray means you should pass on that batch. 

## Drying and seasoning before the pan 

Patting scallops dry is the step that decides whether you get a sear crust or a pale, rubbery surface. Lay them on paper towels, press gently, and turn them so both flat sides lose their moisture. 

Dry them for a few minutes while the pan heats, and salt and pepper them right before they go in. Salt drawn out early pulls moisture back to the surface, which works against you. 

Trim the small side muscle if it is still attached, because it is tough and can pull the scallop out of shape. The muscle is a little tab on the side of the round body, easy to pinch off with your fingers. 

## Heating the skillet to the right point 

A hot skillet is the center of scallop searing, and a cast-iron skillet or a heavy stainless pan holds that heat well. Set the pan over medium-high heat and let it come up fully before adding any fat. 

Add a neutral oil with a high smoke point, such as grapeseed or canola, and wait until it shimmers and moves easily. Butter alone burns at searing heat, so keep it for the baste rather than the first contact. 

If the pan is not hot enough, the scallops release water and stew in it. A properly heated pan gives a steady sizzle the moment the scallop touches the surface. 

## How to saute scallops in the pan 

Pan searing scallops means laying them in the hot pan with space between them so the heat stays high. Work in batches if your skillet is crowded, because a full pan drops the temperature fast. 

Place each scallop flat side down and leave it alone. Moving it around during the first minute breaks the contact that builds the sear color and crust. 

Turn each scallop once with tongs when the edges look opaque and the underside has a deep brown crust. The searing scallops in a hot pan need only one turn, so resist flipping them back and forth. 

- Pat the scallops dry and season one side.
- Heat the skillet over medium-high until the oil shimmers.
- Lay scallops in the pan with space between them.
- Sear undisturbed until a brown crust forms.
- Turn once, then baste with butter.
- Remove when the center turns opaque.
 

## Scallop searing time and doneness 

Scallop searing time depends on the size of the scallop and the heat of your pan. A large sea scallop needs about a minute and a half on the first side and a shorter time after the turn. 

Look for a center that is just opaque and still tender, with a little translucence left at the very middle. Overcooked scallops turn firm and chewy, so pull them early rather than late. 

Smaller scallops take less time, so watch the pan instead of the clock. Let the look of the crust and the feel of the flesh guide you. 
| Scallop size | First side | After turning | 
| Large sea scallop | Until deep brown crust | Brief, just to finish | 
| Medium sea scallop | Shorter sear | Very quick turn | 
| Small bay scallop | Seconds only | Stir, do not sear |  

## Basting with butter for flavor 

Butter basting finishes seared scallops with a nutty richness that oil alone cannot give. Lower the heat slightly after you turn the scallops, then add a knob of butter and let it foam. 

Tip the pan and spoon the foaming butter over the tops of the scallops for a few seconds. A crushed garlic clove or a sprig of thyme in the butter adds aroma without overpowering the shellfish. 

Searing scallops in butter from the start is risky at high heat, because milk solids scorch. Adding butter near the end keeps its flavor clean and protects the crust you already built. 

## Lemon butter sauce to finish the plate 

A lemon butter sauce turns [pan seared scallops](/articles/pan-seared-scallops-preparation-dinner-timing-material-45538/) into a plated dish with almost no extra work. Lift the scallops out, pour off excess fat, and add a squeeze of lemon and a little cold butter to the hot pan. 

Swirl the pan off the heat so the butter melts into a glossy sauce, then spoon it over the scallops. Capers, chopped parsley or a spoon of white wine can go in with the lemon if you want a sharper scallop sauce. 

Serve pan seared scallops with lemon butter right away, over something that soaks up the sauce. Soft polenta, mashed potato or a bed of greens works well, and the dish keeps the focus on the crust. 

## Avoiding a watery pan or a rubbery bite 

[Watery scallops](/articles/watery-scallops-why-they-release-water-and-how-to-cook-them/) in the pan are almost always wet scallops or scallops that were not dried. Soaking up surface moisture with paper towels solves the second problem, and asking for dry-packed scallops solves the first. 

A rubbery bite means the scallops stayed on the heat too long or the pan was too cool at the start. Small scallops overcook within seconds, so keep them moving or cook them in a sauce instead. 

A crowded pan is another cause of a pale surface, because the scallops cool the oil as they touch it. Give each scallop room and cook a second batch if you need to. 

## Questions About Cooking Seared Scallops 

### How do you get a good sear on scallops? 

A good sear on scallops comes from three things: dry dry-packed scallops, a very hot skillet and leaving them undisturbed. Pat the surface dry, add oil to a shimmering pan, and do not move the scallops until a brown crust forms. 

### How long should you sear scallops? 

Scallop searing time depends on size and pan heat rather than a fixed clock. A large sea scallop takes roughly a minute and a half on the first side, and a much shorter time after you turn it. Pull them when the center is just opaque. 

### Can you saute scallops in butter? 

You can saute scallops in butter, but butter burns at the high heat a sear needs. Start the scallops in a little oil, then add butter near the end and baste the tops with the foaming fat for flavor. 

### What sauce goes with pan seared scallops? 

A lemon butter sauce is the natural partner for pan seared scallops, because the acid cuts the richness of the butter. Capers, parsley or a splash of white wine can go into the same pan sauce. 

### Why do my scallops release water in the pan? 

Scallops release water when they are wet-packed or not dried before cooking. Water in the pan lowers the heat and steams the surface, so buy dry-packed scallops and press them on paper towels first. A hot pan also keeps the moisture from pooling. 

### Do you rinse scallops before cooking? 

Rinsing scallops does more harm than good, because it adds surface water you then have to remove again. Pat them dry with paper towels instead, and trim any tough side muscle before they go in the pan.
