# Seafood Sustainability Metrics: What Gets Measured and How to Read It

Learn what seafood sustainability metrics measure, how rating scales and LCA results work, and how to read them when planning a menu.

Seafood sustainability metrics are the scores and labels that describe how a fishery or farm affects the environment, and this page explains what each one measures and how to read it. A rating condenses many separate indicators into one mark, which makes it easy to quote and easy to misread. The sections below separate stock status from fishing method impact, show how a life cycle assessment (LCA) is read, and explain how to use any of these numbers at the seafood counter or on a menu. 

## What a seafood rating actually scores 

A seafood sustainability rating scores a specific fishery or farm, not a species in general, so the same fish can carry different marks from different sources. Most scales weigh stock status, which describes whether a wild population can keep replacing what is caught. They also fold in fishing method impact, such as bycatch rate and damage to seabed habitat. Because each scheme chooses its own sustainability indicators and weights, two eco-scores for the same product may not be comparable. 

## How to read Seafood Watch ratings 

Seafood Watch ratings sort seafood into three tiers: Best Choice, Good Alternative and Avoid. The Best Choice Good Alternative Avoid scale answers one question, which is how the fishing or farming operation affects the species and its habitat. A Best Choice mark reflects a well-managed source with low impact, while an Avoid mark flags a serious concern such as overfishing or destructive gear. The label describes the source of that product, so check the fishery or farm listed and not only the species name. 

## Reading LCA results for a seafood menu 

A life cycle assessment (LCA seafood) adds up the environmental impact categories of a product from capture or feed through processing, transport and waste. Results appear per kilogram of edible seafood, so the functional unit and the system boundary matter as much as the totals. The carbon footprint method within an LCA may count only greenhouse gases, while a full study also reports land use, water use and nutrient release. A cook can use LCA results to compare two dishes, provided both numbers come from the same study and boundary. 

## Questions on seafood sustainability metrics 

### What do seafood sustainability metrics measure? 

Seafood sustainability metrics measure the environmental performance of a specific fishery or farm across several indicators. They cover stock status, bycatch rate, habitat damage from the fishing method impact, and emissions counted through a life cycle assessment. Each scheme sets its own indicators and rating scales, so a single score is a summary and not a full picture. 

### How do I read a seafood sustainability ratings guide? 

A [seafood sustainability ratings](/articles/sustainable-seafood-basics/) guide is read by first finding the exact fishery or farm named, then checking what the scale means. Confirm whether the rating covers the wild stock, the gear used or the whole supply chain. Compare ratings only when they come from the same program, because different eco-scores weigh environmental impact categories differently. 

### What is a life cycle assessment for seafood? 

A life cycle assessment for seafood totals the environmental effects of a product from capture or feed through processing, transport and disposal. It reports results per unit of edible seafood, so the functional unit and system boundary shape the numbers. Reading LCA results means checking those two choices before comparing one seafood with another. 

### Why can the same species carry different sustainability ratings? 

The same species can carry different seafood sustainability ratings because each rating judges a distinct fishery or farm. Stock status and fishing method impact vary by region, gear and management, and each program weighs those sustainability indicators its own way. Read the source named on the label before you treat two scores for one species as equal.
