# How to Avoid Bad Seafood Purchases

Learn how to avoid bad seafood purchases by checking smell, texture, eyes, gills and shellfish shells, plus label and origin checks before you buy.

How to avoid bad seafood purchases comes down to using your senses at the counter before any money changes hands. Smell, touch and look at the fish or shellfish, then read the label and ask where it came from. A few quick checks catch stale fish and spoiled seafood before they reach your kitchen. 

## Smell and texture checks first 

Fresh fish smells of clean sea or nothing much at all, so a sharp ammonia or sour note is a spoilage indicator. Press the flesh with a clean finger and watch whether the dent fills back in; soft flesh that stays dimpled points to stale fish. Fish should feel firm and slightly springy, not slimy or sticky on the surface. Trust your nose over any display ice, because cold masking does not remove a sour smell. 

## Read the eyes, gills and shellfish 

Clear, bulging eyes and bright red gills are signs of freshness in whole fish. Sunken, cloudy eyes and dull gray or brown gills are bad fish signs, so ask the fishmonger for another piece. Live shellfish such as clams and mussels should have closed shells or close when tapped, and an open shell that stays open is a reason to return or discard it. Shrimp and crab should smell sweet, and any blackening at the edges is worth questioning. 

## Check labels and the fishmonger 

Label and origin checks tell you whether seafood was handled well before it reached the counter. Look for a clear species name, a country of origin and a date mark, and ask what the label does not show. A reputable fishmonger keeps fish on plenty of ice, separates species and answers questions about sourcing without hesitation. Counter purchase mistakes include buying from a display that looks warm or crowded. 

## Questions about choosing fresh seafood 

### How can I avoid bad fish at the counter? 

Avoid bad fish at the counter by checking smell, firmness, eyes and gills before you buy. Ask for a piece from the back of the display if the front looks tired. Walk away when the fish smells sour or the flesh stays dented after a gentle press. A short inspection of fresh fish selection saves a spoiled meal. 

### What are the signs of spoiled seafood? 

The [signs of spoiled seafood](/articles/signs-of-spoiled-seafood-fish-shrimp-and-lobster/) include a sour or ammonia smell, slimy surfaces and flesh that falls apart under light pressure. Cloudy eyes and gray gills on whole fish point the same way. Open shellfish shells that do not close when tapped are another clear sign of spoilage. Any one of these signals is enough to refuse the purchase. 

### Is it safe to buy fish that smells strongly? 

No, a strong fishy or ammonia smell is not a safe sign and should keep you from buying. Fresh fish carries a mild sea smell rather than a heavy one. A strong odor suggests the fish has been sitting too long, even when it looks cold on ice. Ask the fishmonger to open a fresh box or choose another species. 

### What should I check on seafood labels? 

Check the species name, country of origin and any date mark on the seafood label. Wild or farmed status and the name of the producer help you judge how the fish was handled. A label without clear origin or species is a reason to ask questions before buying. Keep the receipt so you can return or discard seafood that fails your checks at home.
