# Fish Pie Sauce

Learn how to build a fish pie sauce from butter, flour, milk and fish stock, plus parsley and cheese variations and tips for a smooth, pourable texture.

Fish pie sauce is a creamy white sauce that binds the fish and keeps the filling moist. The base is béchamel, a milk sauce thickened with butter and flour. Swapping part of the milk for fish stock or poaching liquid gives the sauce a deeper seafood flavor. The sauce is made on the stove before the pie is assembled and baked. 

## Making the base sauce step by step 

To make fish pie sauce, start by melting butter and stirring in an equal weight of flour. Cook this paste, called a roux, until it loses its raw flour smell but stays pale. Add warm milk and fish stock a little at a time, whisking until each addition is smooth. Simmer gently while stirring until the sauce coats the back of a spoon. 

## Getting the right thickness for baking 

Fish pie sauce should be thicker than a pouring sauce, because raw fish releases water as it bakes. Thickening with flour works by ratio, so more roux per cup of liquid gives a firmer sauce. Aim for a sauce that holds a trail when you draw a finger across the coated spoon. A slightly cooled sauce gives mashed potato a firmer surface to sit on. 

## Parsley, cheese and other flavor variations 

Stirring in flavorings at the end gives fish pie sauce a different character for each fish. Parsley sauce comes from adding plenty of chopped fresh parsley, which suits smoked haddock and white fish. For cheese sauce, sometimes called Mornay, stir grated hard cheese in off the heat so it melts smoothly. Mustard, lemon zest, dill or a splash of cream can lift a plain white sauce further. 

## Fish pie sauce questions answered 

### Can I make fish pie sauce without fish stock? 

Yes, fish pie sauce can be made with milk alone or with milk and vegetable stock. Poaching the fish in the milk first gives it a gentle seafood taste before you build the roux. Strain the poaching milk to remove skin and small bones before using it. 

### Why is my fish pie sauce lumpy? 

Lumps in fish pie sauce form when cold liquid hits the hot roux too quickly. Adding warm liquid in small amounts while whisking steadily prevents most clumps. A lumpy sauce can be rescued by whisking hard or pressing it through a fine sieve. 

### Can I make fish pie sauce ahead of time? 

Yes, fish pie sauce can be made ahead and kept covered in the fridge. Press parchment directly onto the surface to stop a skin from forming. Safe storage time depends on the freshness of the stock and your fridge temperature. Warm the sauce gently and whisk in a little milk if it has set too firm. 

### What is the difference between béchamel and velouté for fish pie? 

Béchamel is milk thickened with roux, while velouté is stock thickened the same way. A fish velouté made with fish stock tastes lighter and more savory than a milk sauce. A fish pie sauce can sit between the two by using a mix of milk and stock.
